Home > Ask a Question > BBS > Plumbing > Pelican

Plumbing

Not Logged in.
Moderator Moderated by Handyman Login | Register
RSS
Font Size:
   View Style:  Flat   Tree
Post Reply | Post New Message
Title/Content Author

Best Water Softener

 03/27/2007 03:12 PM mikejh1
Indent

Salt free softeners

03/31/2007 08:31 AM Gary Slusser
Indent

water treatment

04/15/2007 07:57 PM qwerty999
Indent

Pelican water softners

04/15/2007 09:58 PM baileyboy
Indent

Pelican

04/16/2007 02:13 PM qwerty999

My argument is that it must not be advertised as a softener or give any implication that it does what a softener does. Misleading advertising is inappropriate at best and false advertising is fraudulent at worst. This item is often labeled as a filter/softener.

The media is NFS certified against Standard 61, which means that the media adds nothing to the drinking water that would cause adverse health effects. It states nothing concerning the water production or quality.

It is also listed as an ion exchange media. This means it is one of three things: an anion media, a cation media, or a mixed bed media (which I doubt). All resin media, whether cation or anion need to be regenerated or replaced in order to do the job, which is to exchange positively or negatively charged ions for the oppositely charges ions at varying rates and durations.

If the exchange media doesn’t have a means to ‘cleanse’ itself, then it becomes exhausted and must be replaced. Furthermore, I not am unaware of an exchange media that matches the claims of scale build up in piping that Pelican advertises. I would love to learn how these claims are justified.

A” 90-day-money-back” may be just enough time before the owner realizes the effectiveness the investment. The 600,000-gallon tag that this is what the media is ‘designed’ to do, is a long way from any assurance that it actually will last that long. I can’t imagine how difficult to get your money back if not satisfied. I ma sure there are hurdles to jump before that would happen. Who knows?

Still further, any water treatment company that supplies so little actual information concerning the technology needs to be investigated before any investment is set forth.

The seller/manufacturer has no awareness of the actual water quality or the customers’ usage and so any claim must be taken as a panacea and that is very risky. All water treatment sellers must have at least an understanding of the objectives for which a system is to be used.

I hope you have success with your purchase but I wouldn’t change my views on this particular product primarily because of the lack of technical information, methods of advertising and lack of qualifications.

Good luck with your decision.
Andy Christensen, CWS

Member Since
04/02/2005

Total Contributions
40 Posts

Post Reply | Watch this Topic
Indent

More ? on this no salt softner

04/24/2007 11:45 AM winniefgn
Indent

A balancing act

04/24/2007 09:47 PM qwerty999
Indent

Hi Andy Christensen/qwerty999

04/26/2007 11:39 AM Gary Slusser
Indent

Hello, back at you.

04/26/2007 09:04 PM qwerty999
Indent

Kinetico

11/07/2007 05:15 AM chris1966
Indent

Kinetico 4040

11/15/2007 03:40 PM qwerty999
Indent

Kinetico with high salt usage

01/10/2009 01:27 AM CB7777
Indent

Kinetico salt efficiency

01/12/2009 05:35 PM qwerty999
Indent

Kinetico water softener

01/14/2009 09:59 AM Bigmama7
Indent

water running

01/14/2009 03:56 PM qwerty999
Indent

water running

01/18/2009 05:21 PM Bigmama7
Indent

where are you

01/18/2009 08:08 PM justalurker
Indent

Gear replacement

01/20/2009 05:15 PM qwerty999
Indent

RE: softener

01/16/2009 02:40 AM justalurker
Indent

Water-softening confusion

01/06/2009 06:18 AM Arvidd
Indent

no salt water softeners

01/12/2009 09:12 AM brucet50
Indent

No Salt Water Softener

01/12/2009 06:04 PM bpayne611
Indent

Pelican

01/14/2009 03:52 AM artist117
Indent

Confused

05/11/2009 07:01 PM Waterrep
Indent

A balancing act

05/12/2008 07:48 AM mrbanjo
Indent

Excema

05/11/2009 06:23 PM Waterrep
Indent

mrbanjo

05/08/2008 05:27 PM mrbanjo
Indent

Research

05/11/2009 07:08 PM Waterrep
Indent

No Salt Water Softeners

05/08/2008 05:30 PM mrbanjo
Indent

Pelican Water Softener

05/12/2008 02:22 AM artist117
Indent

No Salt Water Softeners

05/12/2008 07:44 AM mrbanjo
Indent

Easywater

06/02/2008 03:25 PM lgcd2008
Indent

Pelican

05/11/2009 06:48 PM Waterrep
Indent

NO Salt Water Softeners

07/09/2008 03:32 PM bpayne611
Indent

NO-SALT Water Softener Alternative

10/22/2008 06:15 PM healthmindedbob
Indent

hocus pocus hard ---water all gone

10/22/2008 06:32 PM qwerty999
Indent

Yeah right

12/17/2008 01:38 PM kwatters
Indent

Don't Buy this

05/05/2009 04:25 PM kgriner
Indent

Life Source No-Salt System Not Good for Hard Water

05/13/2009 09:55 AM daviddames
Indent

Water systems

05/13/2009 10:28 AM suegauta
Indent

Water Test for Hardness

05/13/2009 10:43 AM daviddames
Indent

Hardnes testing

05/13/2009 02:10 PM Waterrep
Indent

Water Grain Hardness Level

05/13/2009 08:12 PM alexofthemed
Indent

Help?

05/13/2009 02:42 PM Waterrep
Indent

Does Good Job for What it Is

05/13/2009 04:37 PM daviddames
Indent

Good job

05/13/2009 04:49 PM Waterrep
Indent

How Many have 20+ Grains of Hardness?

05/13/2009 05:06 PM daviddames
Indent

Pelican Water Technologies

05/13/2009 05:58 PM suegauta
Indent

Grains of hardness

05/15/2009 02:12 PM Waterrep
Indent

Best Water Softener

05/11/2009 06:43 PM Waterrep
Indent

help!

05/12/2009 02:37 PM suegauta
Indent

Help

05/13/2009 01:57 PM Waterrep
Indent

"Water softening," water blahh"

05/16/2009 12:23 AM Arvidd
Indent

Words mean something.

05/16/2009 12:15 PM Waterrep
Indent

What really works?

05/17/2009 10:13 PM qwerty999
Indent

City water

05/18/2009 01:40 PM Waterrep
Indent

Yes, but....

05/18/2009 11:00 PM qwerty999
Indent

Maybe we're getting somewhere . . .

05/20/2009 02:13 PM Arvidd
Indent

Practicality

05/21/2009 12:59 PM Waterrep
Indent

thanks

08/04/2009 11:18 AM tarwood
Indent

Totally correct

06/08/2009 10:53 AM Dawn91
Indent

Thoughts

06/23/2009 08:57 AM bewalsh2418
Indent

Higher end Whirlpool softener...?

06/23/2009 10:02 AM justalurker




About  | Press Room  | FAQ  | Contact  | Sitemap  | Privacy Policy  | Terms of Use  | Help

© 2009 BobVila.com