Home > Ask a Question > BBS > The Rough Cut Show Forum > Question For Eli

The Rough Cut Show Forum

Not Logged in.
Moderator Moderated by TChisel Login | Register
RSS

!! FORUM ALERT !!


Dear Rough Cut Show Forum Member,

Tommy MacDonald's discussion forum, The Rough Cut Show Forum, is moving to a new location. The Rough Cut Show forum, on BobVila.com, will no longer be accepting post as of Tuesday, June 17th 2008 @ 11AM EST. Due to the current privacy policies at BobVila.com we will not automatically transfer your post or user information. If you would like to continue to be a part of a growing woodworking community, please follow this link and sign-up for the new and improved Forum at http://www.TChisel.com/forum/ .

Sincerely,
Staff of BobVila.com
Font Size:
   View Style:  Flat   Tree
Post Reply | Post New Message
Title/Content Author

Question For Eli

04/05/2008 12:49 PM CMiddleton

Eli,

Some of the students in this class are less experienced than others. They may not understand the joinery being used or why. They may think why not grab the old router or festool and make a loose tenon joint. Here are what I think the reasons are, if I am incorrect please correct me. I do not want to sound like a know-it-all. I certainly am not at the level of craftsmen either Tommy or you. But I think we would like to know why certain things are being done to help further our education down this journey of the “Crazy Leg Table” project. For our next project, we will all understand why many of the basic joinery is be completed the why it is and the temptation of grabbing the router or festool will not be there.

My understanding of tenon design of using haunches and twin tenons for any tenon over five inches long is as follows:

The haunches are used to help the apron from twisting over time and the twin tenons over fine inches will tend prevent joint failure due to wood movement over the span. In addition there is more glue surface for the joint.

The double tenon on the divider is used to increase glue surface on long grain to long grain surfaces.

Chuck

Member Since
02/15/2008

Total Contributions
106 Posts

Post Reply | Watch this Topic
Indent

One more question Eli

04/05/2008 12:51 PM CMiddleton
Indent

Answers for Chuck

04/05/2008 08:54 PM EliCleveland
Indent

........little crumbs

04/06/2008 05:48 AM NLamens






 

About | FAQ | Contact | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Help
© BobVila.com 2008