Home > Ask a Question > BBS > Roofing and Siding > The Superiortiy of Plywood is a Myth

Roofing and Siding

Not Logged in.
Moderator Moderated by Handyman Login | Register
RSS
Font Size:
   View Style:  Flat   Tree
Post Reply | Post New Message
Title/Content Author

Particle board vs Plywood

 10/10/2004 05:39 PM colleengervolino
Indent

OSB or Plywood

10/15/2004 11:39 AM homebild
Indent

OSB? Never again

06/19/2005 04:03 AM prajna
Indent

OSB...not what claimed to be.

06/19/2005 10:56 AM dodgeroof
Indent

The Superiortiy of Plywood is a Myth

06/26/2005 10:31 PM homebild

That OSB is inferior to plywood, or that plywood is superior to OSB board, is a myth that is propogated by the ignorant.

In fact OSB is superior to plywood in several key areas which include:

-stronger sheer strength and greater resistance to blowing off in high winds
-better ability to span distance and bear weight per equal thicknesses.


OSB also shows no difference at all in nail holding power to plywood.

OSB has been proven to actually repel water better than plywood.

All major code, manufacturers and scientific studies and organizations list plywood and OSB, both engineered wood products, as EQUAL in overall performance with only minor differences between the two for application consideration.

If your OSB rotted eaily, it was likely not OSB at all, but rather a separate grade of waferboard or 'Aspenite' which is not the same thing.

In my 30 years of homebuidling experience, I have never seen any major differences in performance between OSB and plywood and have even conducted my own tests on the products which support the scientific findings.

OSB is more environmentally friendly than ply because it uses wood products that would otherwise be sent to the garbage heap.

OSB makes better use of limited natural resources getting more product out of a single tree with less waste.

Here is a helpful link to dispel the many myths about OSB and plywood:

http://www.umass.edu/bmatwt/publications/articles/osb_vs_plywood.html

Member Since
01/29/2003

Total Contributions
2065 Posts

Post Reply | Watch this Topic
Indent

OSBS

06/27/2005 06:40 PM dodgeroof
Indent

Nothing Personal

06/29/2005 08:52 AM homebild
Indent

If money is the most important issue ...........

07/01/2005 09:35 PM dodgeroof
Indent

osb

07/02/2005 07:15 PM Piffin
Indent

Will OSB be OK.

07/28/2005 01:59 PM sterusso
Indent

osb subfloor

07/29/2005 06:12 PM Piffin
Indent

Thanks for the Input

07/31/2005 01:02 PM homebild
Indent

homebild & Piffen

11/10/2007 08:25 PM ama572
Indent

BTW a Word on Price.

07/31/2005 01:12 PM homebild
Indent

Floors

07/31/2005 01:14 PM homebild






 

About | FAQ | Contact | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Help | bobvilacontractors
© BobVila.com 2008