Home > Ask a Question > BBS > Roofing and Siding > homebild & Piffen

Roofing and Siding

Not Logged in.
Moderator Moderated by Handyman Login | Register
RSS
Font Size:
   View Style:  Flat   Tree
Post Reply | Post New Message
Title/Content Author

Particle board vs Plywood

 10/10/2004 05:39 PM colleengervolino
Indent

OSB or Plywood

10/15/2004 11:39 AM homebild
Indent

OSB? Never again

06/19/2005 04:03 AM prajna
Indent

OSB...not what claimed to be.

06/19/2005 10:56 AM dodgeroof
Indent

The Superiortiy of Plywood is a Myth

06/26/2005 10:31 PM homebild
Indent

OSBS

06/27/2005 06:40 PM dodgeroof
Indent

Nothing Personal

06/29/2005 08:52 AM homebild
Indent

If money is the most important issue ...........

07/01/2005 09:35 PM dodgeroof
Indent

osb

07/02/2005 07:15 PM Piffin
Indent

Will OSB be OK.

07/28/2005 01:59 PM sterusso
Indent

osb subfloor

07/29/2005 06:12 PM Piffin
Indent

Thanks for the Input

07/31/2005 01:02 PM homebild
Indent

homebild & Piffen

11/10/2007 08:25 PM ama572

Homebild-Do you work for an OSB manufacturer?

You guys may be comparing apples and oranges a bit here. keep in mind that there are 2 grades of plywood (interior /exterior). OSB has different types of grades depending on usage.

I think most would agree that if the usage is for an area that may sustain more than one month of periodic rain/wetness before being able to be 'roofed' over or vapor barriered, that plywood is much better in general.

For example, OSB floor edges will turn up if it stays wet for longer than a month, whereas plywood would take a lot longer. Obviously depends on how often it rains and how wet it stays. Some builders are notorious slow and behind the gun and cut corners.

Homebild, BTW, most OSB that builders use has LESS sheer and lateral strength than plywood. Keep in mind that tobacco companies told folks smoking was safe and didn't cause cancer either.

And while you 'builders' sit and crow about years of experience, mull over this information is coming from a retiring PhD Structural Engineer with 40 years "experience" with copious laboratory/field testing experience.

OSB is almost always used because it's cheaper, not because it gives superior structural support over plywood. Give it a rest folks.

Member Since
11/10/2007

Total Contributions
1 Posts

Post Reply | Watch this Topic
Indent

BTW a Word on Price.

07/31/2005 01:12 PM homebild
Indent

Floors

07/31/2005 01:14 PM homebild






 

About | FAQ | Contact | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Help | bobvilacontractors
© BobVila.com 2008