How Many Tools Does a Good Multi-Tool Need?

A century ago, knife-maker Wenger (of Swiss Army Knife fame) started a debate that only got louder in 1983 when Tim Leatherman, the eponymous inventor of his multi-tool, started selling pocket toolboxes. The question is how many tools are too many in a multi-tool? Or conversely, how many are too few? Sages wiser than me haven’t divined the truth, so I won’t try.

How Many Tools Does a Good Multi-Tool Need?

Photo: CRKT

The issue has surfaced again with a new variation from CRKT Tools (Columbia River Knife and Tool)—the multi-tool 9200 designed by Ed Van Hoy and Tom Stokes.

Multi-Tool

Photo: CRKT

Just four appendages fold out of the burly case: a Phillips screwdriver, a flat-tip driver, a 2.25-inch knife and a 2.5-inch saw. Locking liners hold all of them safely, and the two drivers are spring-loaded, flashing out with amazing speed at the touch of two small buttons on the case. Thumb studs bring out the blades.

The 9200 comes with a magnetic connector that attaches nine heads onto the Phillips driver shaft. Die cuts on both sides of the case make it an acceptable box wrench for a variety of nuts and bolts, metric and standard. (And each is also billed as a bottle opener). Last, there’s a four-gauge wire stripper that cleverly uses the knife.

Compare this almost Shaker-simple multi-tool with Wenger’s world-record, $1,000 pocket porcupine, below. Surely between the two we have the alpha and omega of the category.

Wegner Muti-Tool

Photo: Riceowls

I won’t make a judgment here other than to say CRKT has priced it right—$50. The whole package is very robustly assembled; it’s not going to fall apart too soon. On the other hand, the 9200 is a big, thick slug of metal, weighing 5.1 ounces without the case or ancillary driver bits.

Is it heavy and skimpy or beefy and just right? You tell me in the comments.

Top 5 Tool Buying Tips
In Search of Antique Tools
The Essential Toolbox