Lots of good dialogue and opinions here. I've done both and I have to say the drywall option is the best looking...and it doen't feel/look so much like a basement. As far as access; I used simple metal airvents-like a cold air return for critical access points. Painted to match the ceiling they look very natural and unobtrusive. I also take photos with key dimensions written in bold marker and keep them on file in case I ever have to get into something, I'm not punching out good drywall to find the turn-off or HVAC shunt valve.
Yes, unfortunately, dropped ceilings don't cut it here in Atlanta. I would suggest getting a digital camera and taking a zillion pictures. Doesn't cost anything and you can burn a CD with the images. Also I ran fishing line up and down the joists in case I had to pull wires. Using heating grills for access is a great idea!
No sense beating the horse more but drywall is really the way to go. Pipes run in ceilings between the first and second floor all the time. You'll appreciate the value of the drywall personally and when you sell the house. I also like the idea of using vents for access.
- 15 Old House Features We Shouldn't Abandon
- 17 Tiny Bathrooms We Love
- Make Your Bed: 9 DIY Headboards
- Insanely Easy 60-Minute Home Improvements
- Space-Saving Solutions for Tiny Bedrooms
- 9 Perfect Color Combos for Your Home
- 22 Tiny Houses We Love
- See the Most Highly Anticipated Colors for 2015
- What's the Best Color for Living Rooms?
- Favorite Space-Saving Double-Duty Furniture
- 10 Low-Cost DIY Home Security Solutions
- Redecorate Without Spending a Dime: 10 Ideas
- 10 Houseplants You Can Grow Anywhere
- 9 Amazing Mobile Home Makeovers
- 10 Doable Designs for a DIY Rug
- 9 Alternative Uses for Toothpaste
- Live Large in a (Very) Small Space
- 8 Cheap and Unique DIY Nightstands
- 15 Eye-Catching Options for Your Front Door
- Supersize Your Small Bath with 8 Pro Tips
- Don't Try This at Home: 7 Dangerous DIYs
- 10 Simple Woodworking Projects
- Is There Anything Vinegar Can't Do?
- 7 Incredible Uses for Salvaged Lumber
- 12 Tiny Gardens You Can Grow on a Tabletop
- 16 Sneaky Storage Ideas
- 10 Surprisingly Smart Solutions for Junk Drawers
- Bright & Bold Colors for Your Front Door
- DIY Bookcases: 16 Easy Project Ideas
- Don't Make These 7 Fireplace Mistakes