The Dean of Home Renovation & Repair Advice

COMMUNITY FORUM

monniert

06:10AM | 01/23/10
Member Since: 01/22/10
1 lifetime posts
Bvwindows
Can some one tell me the truth about American Craftsman windows - 9500 series with energy star rating - Kansas is my local.

I am a DIY on a limited budget - on a scale of 1-10 how good or bad are they for the money.

I would prefer to go with Simonton but they will not sell to a DIY.

I know installation is everything but with that aside is the unit worth what they cost.

Does any one have any history with them - the 8500 or 9500 series - not the 1200 or lower quality series.

And by history I am asking for history where you know the installation was not the problem

or does any one know where a DIY can purchase Simonton direct and not through a contractor.

Thanks in advance for any help/input

Window Hunting

wrh675

07:08AM | 02/01/10
Member Since: 01/31/10
1 lifetime posts
I bought the 8500 series (2) of the for the upstairs of my older farm house. the 2 upper sashs on both of them lost the seal within 5 years, glass became cloudy between the panes. They sent me new panes free of charge. now I just noticed that one of the replaced panes broke for no apparent reason, that one they refused to replace...claimed it was from the house settling. all the other upstairs windows are fine (6). Also vinyl windows that I bought from Lowes, can't recall the brand. Downstairs, I used Pella replacement windows that I bought from Carter Lumber (8). Aluminum-clad wood. Cost a little more but look and perform great. I would rate the American Craftsman at a 2. Don't make the same mistake I did. If you plan on keeping your house for a while don't buy them.....you get what you pay for!!!!


Post a reply as Anonymous

Photo must be in JPG, GIF or PNG format and less than 5MB.

Reply_choose_button

captcha
type the code from the image

Anonymous

Post_new_button or Login_button
Register

Follow Us

horizontal divider
facebook
 
webapp2