08:33PM | 08/22/10
Member Since: 05/11/08
10 lifetime posts
Hello again.

My house was built in 1995. I have been trying to correct a poorly design/poorly installed HVAC (gas heat and central A/C) system

for my home over the past couple of years. My house has two systems. One

for the main floor and basement and one for the upstairs. Thanks to your previous advice I was able to

correct errors in the ducting in the room over the garage. I did the heatpro calculations and purchased

a CFM meter to check how the actual delivery aligned to calculated.

I won't repeat all the history but the addition of another return (8" round) and closing off a couple supply vents (in rooms closest to furnace that

had two supplies one was shut down) made a large difference

and now the comfort in the over the garage bonus room is much better. I also had the bonus room floor spray foam insulated as well from the garage ceiling.

I still had a strange problem that whenever the second story blower went on the basement door would slam shut. I've also had problems with gas water heaters

backdrafting in the summer and the furnaces sometimes backdrafting in the winter. A couple years ago I installed a Tjernlund Draft Inducer and control system to

fix the backdrafting problem when either of the furnaces or hot water tanks fired. I haven't had backdrafting since this was installed. I still have

slamming basement door though.

The symptoms only seemed related to the second floor system (blower) not the main floor system. I assumed shoddy return air trunk sealing was the problem.

Today I decided to take a closer look. As expected the 6" round take offs from the basement trunk were just elbows dropped on top of trunk

with a hole slightly larger than the diameter of the pipe. As much as 1/2" of gap most of the way around the elbow/trunk.

So that is certainly contributing to the return leakage and negative pressure in the basement. What I found next really threw me however.

Hidden on the top of the return plenum I found a 6x14" grill mounted providing air intake from the basement directly into the

return plenum. Recall this is the HVAC system for the second floor not the main floor or basement. Worse still the grill was directly on top of the

horizontal plenum right above the vertical trunk running from the air handler (the point of maximum static pressure).

The return grill was deliberate by the installer but I can't think why he would want air supply from the basement for the second story unit when

he didn't do the same on the main floor system. Also the vent is large and so close to the blower it must really compromise the return effectiveness

from the furthest returns which are 60-70 feet away.

So I removed the grill and covered it over with sheet metal and duct tape (the proper metal type tape). I then sealed the take offs on top side of

plenum except for two that are buried in a finished ceiling. The door no longer slams shut when the blower goes on.

So this has been a long preamble.

My question(s)..

1) Is there a legitimate reason the installer would put a cold air return direct to the basement?

2) Could he have meant to put this return on the main floor unit to be a return for the entire basement area?

3) Isn't it a well known problem when you put returns in the same area as gas burners due to negative pressures and

the increased probability of backdrafting?

4) Was this extra return vent just to allow blower to meet CFM target instead of properly sizing the return plenum

and duct system? A band aid if you will to a half done duct design/install?

5) The return grill was on the top side of the plenum just under the joist so not visible. Its almost as if it was

being hidden. If it was deliberate why not mount it on the side of the plenum so it could be in view and cleaned. Its location is very suspicious.


11:57AM | 08/23/10
Member Since: 05/11/08
10 lifetime posts
Good point about circulating the back drafted products through the house, notably all the bedrooms on the second floor. Fortunately we didn't have a negative incident.

I guess I'll just leave the erroneous basement return grill sealed and see how the system is balanced once the winter heating system arrives. It could be some fine tuning will be required.

Had I known about this hidden return grill I might have been able to avoid about $500 in draft inducer equipment a couple years ago. I thought my chimney was oversized. Oh well, Learn and Plan to Live!


Post a reply as Anonymous

Photo must be in JPG, GIF or PNG format and less than 5MB.


type the code from the image


Post_new_button or Login_button

Rather than sitting concealed behind closed doors, this closet rod hangs out in the open like a ballet barre. Clothes face... It turns out that many bath and kitchen cleansers contain chemicals that are dangerous to the skin and eyes, and often pro... So often we paint tiny nooks white to make them appear larger, but opting for a dark, dramatic wall color like this one—Be... Chocolate-colored walls and large window frames allow the exposed wood beams to take center stage in this small screened p... If you're not crazy about the idea of commingling plants and pool, this modern variation may be more to your liking. The s... Yes, a freestanding garage can become its own tiny house. Artist Michelle de la Vega has all the comforts of a modern resi... There’s nothing like a new set of cabinet hardware to refresh a room. The possibilities are endless: Go modern, rustic, or... Pursue what's known as the stack effect. To achieve it, open the windows on both the upper and lower floors, and as warm a... Like no other floor type, a checkerboard design works wonders to underscore the retro kitchen theme. Vinyl flooring, ceram... Twine lanterns add pops of crafty—but sophisticated—flair to any outdoor setting. Wrap glue-soaked twine around a balloon ... When securely fastened to a tree or the ceiling of a porch, a pallet and some cushioning make the ideal place to lounge. V... Incorporate nature into your lighting scheme by securing a dead tree in a concrete mold and draping your pendant lamp from... For the cost of a can of exterior paint , you can totally transform your porch. Paint the floor a hue that complements yo... In this urban apartment, a standard-issue patio became a serene and green perch by replacing the typical concrete with gro... If you put the washing machine in the mudroom, you can stop the kids from walking through the house in dirty, grass-staine...
Newsletter_icon Google_plus Facebook Twitter Pinterest Youtube Rss_icon