Flat Roof Advcie
1. First company suggested removing the old roof, laying down tapered insulation (to make sure the water drains) and laying a new rubber roof on top for about $2,000. (work also included some flashing on the wall and brick columns).
2. The next guy said the same (tapered roof) but for $650. This seems almost TOO cheap to be good work.
3. The next guy (who comes with the most recommendations) suggested leaving the old roof on and just laying down the torch applied rubber roof. When I asked why not tapering it, he said he can but it’s expensive and even though the water may sit in areas, nothing’s going to come through this rubber roof. His quote was about $500.
4. The last guy also suggested just laying the rubber roof but said he would take the old roof off before laying the new rubber one down.
Since the suggested work differs so much I’m hoping you guys can throw some advice my way. I’m leaning towards guy #3 just because he’s dome work for people I know (although the cheapest, his work seems the least comprehensive- or do I not need anything more?)
Modified bitumen torch down is not an apprpriate material for this. It has a ten year life expectancy with maintanance. Epdm rubber roofing can last forty years with no maintainance.
How often did you say you want to redo this roof?
here is what the tapered job would include:
-1/8" per foot tapered polyiso insulation
-install fiberglass base sheet
-install firestone app-180 black granule torch applied membrane-sheet metal edging where needed
some white aluminum cap flashing
Does it also seem to you that $650 is way to cheap to be real? Also, the people who recommended just laying a new layer of rubber roofing said that since the roof is not used for anything, I don't need to spend the $$ to do the whole tapering thing. They also said $650 is too cheap.
Any feelings out there?
This guy might do a decent job but he is not enough of a businessman to allow for insurance costs or profit. That makes me question whether he will still be in business to fix any leaks in two years. So if he has good references maybe you want to check your homeowners policy in case he gets hurt on your property, and go ahead and take the gamble on him, banking the savings
- 15 Old House Features We Were Wrong to Abandon
- 17 Tiny Bathrooms We Love
- 20 Insanely Easy 60-Minute Home Improvements
- 70 Gardening Tricks and Ideas for Total Beginners
- 16 Inventive Beds You Can Make Yourself
- Top 10 Classic DIY Projects for the Outdoors
- 15 Once-Popular Household Items That Are Vanishing
- 159 Smart Storage Ideas for the Whole House
- 30 Things Every Adult Should Know How to Do
- 10 Wise Ways to Get Rid of Pests and Critters
- 9 Tried-and-True Methods of Eliminating Weeds
- Top Tips for Keeping Countertops Like New
- 15 Amazing Things You Can Make with $0 Scrap Wood
- 14 Ways to Get More Kitchen Counter Space
- Assembly Required: 15 DIY Kit Homes
- 18 Bathroom Updates You Can Do in 1 Day
- 10 Secret Rooms & Passages in Ordinary Homes
- 10 Room Dividers to Bring Order to Your Space
- 11 Clever Alternatives to Kitchen Cabinets
- 7 Easy Budget-Friendly Backyard Makeovers