The Best Brownie Pans for the Kitchen

Bake delicious brownies, cookies, squares, and more with these specialty pans.

By Sarah Littleton | Updated Jun 30, 2020 12:50 PM

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs.

The Best Brownie Pan Options


Brownies are a go-to dessert for many occasions, and you don’t have to be a chef extraordinaire to bake a wonderful batch. Packed full of chocolate with filling choices like salted caramel, peanut butter, butterscotch, cookie dough, and candy, there are always more brownie recipes to try. The best brownie pan will cook your baked goods evenly and won’t leave a crumbling mess as you remove them. They’re incredibly versatile and can be used to bake other tasty treats like cookies, squares, layers of sheet cake, and crumbles, depending on the pan’s structure.

Brownie pans come in a variety of sizes, so you’ll want to consider what quantities you plan on baking. You may prefer to cut the brownies individually from a basic square pan, or for them to bake separately inside individual molds. Some pans are designed specifically for baking preferences, like crispy corners. Brownie pans most often contain aluminum, steel, and silicone, so consider your material preferences for bakeware. Finally, keep in mind any elements you prioritize, like nonstick capabilities and easy cleaning.

Our Top Picks

With your shopping considerations in mind, choose the best brownie pan for your cooking needs from this list of quality recommendations.

The Best Brownie Pan Option: Wilton Performance Aluminum Square Cake and Brownie Pan


BEST OVERALL: Wilton Performance Aluminum Brownie Pan

This 8-inch Wilton pan comes at a fantastic price and value, since you can use it for a range of baking projects like cakes, squares, and cookies. Its 2-inch depth gives you the flexibility to make thicker, denser desserts or thinner, sheet-like ones. Made with a heavy-gauge aluminum, this Wilton pan is built to last and provides excellent heat distribution. Wilton recommends that users wash the pan in warm soapy water after each use for best results.

The Best Brownie Pan Option: Baker's Edge Nonstick Edge Brownie Pan


EASIEST BATTER POUR: Baker’s Edge Nonstick Edge Brownie Pan

This top pick from Baker’s Edge yields chewy edge pieces across the entire batch: cooks will enjoy pouring the batter seamlessly in the continuous chamber without fussing with individual holes or spreading the mix with a spatula. Its heavy-gauge cast aluminum construction and interior walls ensure even baking, and the pan’s nonstick coating works brilliantly with even the stickiest brownie recipe. This Baker’s Edge pan comes with a nonstick nylon spatula and brownie recipes for inspiration.

The Best Brownie Pan Option: Bakelicious Crispy Corner Brownie Pan


BEST FOR CRISPY CORNERS: Bakelicious Crispy Corner Brownie Pan

This Bakelicious brownie pan features a unique design dedicated to producing gloriously crispy edges. The pan yields 12 brownies with a total of 48 edges in the lattice-like structure, which ensures even cooking. Its durable carbon steel construction is built to last for years and boasts superb heat conducting abilities. The Bakelicious Crispy Corner Brownie Pan has a nonstick coating, and all you have to do is flip the pan over and tap the bottom a few times to easily release the brownies. The pan should be hand washed to preserve the nonstick coating, so you might find those extra edges are a bit of a pain to clean up after cooking.

The Best Brownie Pan Option: Wilton Brownie Bar Pan


BEST SNACK-SIZE MODEL: Wilton Brownie Bar Pan

The Wilton Brownie Bar Pan is designed with 12 separate insets, for bakers who want smaller treats with neat edges and the ability to customize each brownie. The heavy-gauge aluminum mold contains indents between each inset, allowing for better heat distribution between each bar—you’ll find that your brownies cook more quickly in this pan, and they’ll have nice and crispy edges. A bonus to this Wilton model is its nonstick coating, which makes it easy to transfer treats out of the pan. Wilton recommends that cooks wash the pan in warm soapy water after each use to preserve the nonstick coating.

The Best Brownie Pan Option: Wilton Bite-Size Brownie Squares Silicone Mold


BEST BITE-SIZE MODEL: Wilton Bite-Size Brownie Squares Silicone Mold

To cook bite-sized brownies quickly and efficiently, try this silicone mold from Wilton. Ideal for batch cooking for parties and customization, this option bakes 24 mini brownies and can cut down on baking time considerably. This silicone brownie pan is entirely freezer, microwave, oven, and dishwasher safe, so clean up is a breeze. Silicone has built-in nonstick capabilities, so bite-sized brownies will release from the pan with no trouble at all.