--- title: "No More Gunk: The Best Pool Skimmers for Clear Water" description: "We used some of the best pool skimmers to remove leaves, bugs, and other debris. Here's how they performed in our hands-on tests." date: "2023-05-15" modified: "2025-09-04" authors: - name: "Bob Beacham" job_title: "Contributing Writer" link: "https://www.bobvila.com/authors/bob-beacham/" url: "https://www.bobvila.com/articles/best-pool-skimmers/" categories: - "Lawn, Garden & Pool" - "Pool Maintenance" - "Reviews" tags: - "Commerce" - "MPR" --- # No More Gunk: The Best Pool Skimmers for Clear Water ![Best Pool Skimmers]() *Photo: Paul Rankin for BobVila.com* A pool skimmer is a vital tool for maintaining a clean and swim-ready pool. Whether you maintain your pool yourself or rely on a service, there are always moments when leaves, bugs, hair, and other debris mar the waters. A skimmer helps remove that gunk quickly, keeping the pool looking pristine and helping maintain safe water quality. To find the most effective options, we tested eight pool skimmers, evaluating everything from ease of use to durability and cleaning performance. With so many types of pool skimmers available—from classic handheld nets to solar-powered models that roam the water on their own—it can be tough to choose the right one to keep the [pool]() free of debris. The best pool skimmers strike a balance between simplicity and effectiveness, and the differences in price and features can be significant. After hands-on testing, our top recommendation is the [ProTuff Heavy-Duty Fine Mesh Pool Skimmer](), which impressed us with its durable design, fine mesh, and large net size. But there were plenty of other worthy options that came close. Whether you're a new pool owner or upgrading existing gear, this guide will help you choose a skimmer that fits your pool, your routine, and your budget. 1. **BEST OVERALL:** [ProTuff Heavy-Duty Fine Mesh Pool Skimmer]() [↓ *Jump to Review*](<#protuff-heavy-duty-fine-mesh-pool-skimmer>) 2. **BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK:** [PoolWhale Upgrades Telescopic Pool Skimmer]() [↓ *Jump to Review*](<#poolwhale-upgrades-telescopic-pool-skimmer>) 3. **BEST KIT:** [Intex Deluxe Pool Cleaning Maintenance Kit]() [↓ *Jump to Review*](<#intex-deluxe-pool-cleaning-maintenance-kit>) 4. **BEST ROBOTIC:** [Betta SE Solar-Powered Smart Robotic Pool Skimmer]() [↓ *Jump to Review*](<#betta-se-solar-powered-smart-robotic-pool-skimmer>) 5. **BEST HIGH VOLUME:** [PoolWhale Pool Skimmer Net Rake]() [↓ *Jump to Review*](<#poolwhale-pool-skimmer-net-rake>) 6. **BEST FOR QUICK JOBS:** [Sunnyglade Pool Skimming Net]() [↓ *Jump to Review*](<#sunnyglade-pool-skimming-net>) 7. **BEST FLOATING:** [SkimmerMotion Original Automatic Pool Cleaner]() [↓ *Jump to Review*](<#skimmermotion-original-automatic-pool-cleaner>) 8. **BEST COMPACT:** [Poolaza Handheld Skimmer Net]() [↓ *Jump to Review*](<#poolaza-handheld-skimmer-net>) ![Poolaza handheld skimmer]() *Photo: Paul Rankin for BobVila.com* ## Pool Skimmers Comparison | **Product** | **Type** | **Pool suitability** | **Collection method** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | [ProTuff Heavy Duty Fine Mesh Pool Skimmer]() | Manual | All | Net | | [PoolWhale Upgrades Telescopic Pool Skimmer]() | Manual | All | Net | | [Intex Deluxe Pool Cleaning Maintenance Kit]() | Manual | Primarily above-ground (see description) | Net, vacuum, scrub brush | | [Betta SE Solar-Powered Smart Robotic Pool Skimmer]() | Robot skimmer | All | Automatic (into a collection box) | | [PoolWhale Pool Skimmer Net Rake]() | Manual | All | Net | | [Sunnyglade Pool Skimming Net]() | Manual | All | Net | | [SkimmerMotion Original Automatic Pool Cleaner]() | Automatic | Inground and some above-ground | Vacuum | | [Poolaza Handheld Skimmer Net]() | Handheld | Small pools, hot tubs, etc. | Net | ## Our Top Picks The following list offers everything from a budget-friendly pool leaf skimmer to an environmentally-friendly floating robot. Each has been categorized to help potential buyers quickly find the pool skimmer they need. **Our Ratings** | **Functionality** | **5/5** | **Maneuverability** | **5/5** | **Ergonomics** | **4.5/5** | **Build Quality** | **5/5** | **Value** | **4/5** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | If you're tired of flimsy pool nets that bend, tear, or clog easily, this skimmer is a serious upgrade. Designed for durability and performance, it features a deep, double-stitched net that can hold up to 50 pounds of debris—far more than your average skimmer. The aluminum frame feels solid in hand and is built to resist corrosion over time, even with heavy, repeated use. In testing, we immediately noticed how much sturdier this net felt compared to the budget models. The fine mesh does a great job trapping small particles without impeding water flow, and its generous depth makes it ideal for both surface skimming and scooping debris from the pool bottom. The handle connection is winged for added support and screws in securely—just purchase a compatible pole separately. ProTuff sells one, but any standard telescoping pole will work. ![ProTuff skimmer]() *Photo: Paul Rankin for BobVila.com* Some light assembly is required out of the box, but once it's set up, this tool feels like it’s built to last. For anyone looking for a reliable, high-capacity skimmer that can handle regular pool maintenance with ease, this one’s hard to beat. **What our tester says:** “You instantly notice that this skimmer head is of a much higher quality than the standard plastic options. It’s a little pricier, but I think it’ll stand up to heavier use and still be usable several years down the line.”—Paul Rankin, Product Reviews tester and writer **Get the ProTuff pool skimmer at** [**Amazon**](). **Our Ratings** | **Functionality** | **4.8/5** | **Maneuverability** | **5/5** | **Ergonomics** | **4/5** | **Build Quality** | **3.8/5** | **Value** | **4.5/5** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | For those looking for a simple and affordable way to keep the pool clear of leaves and floating debris, the PoolWhale Upgraded Telescopic Pool Skimmer is a great light-duty maintenance option. Priced around $20, it comes ready to use: Just snap the adjustable aluminum pole into place and start skimming. The pole extends from 1.3 to 5 feet, making it especially useful for small above-ground pools, quick spot-cleaning, and spa/fountain maintenance. For larger pools, a compatible pole with longer reach may be necessary. With the help of its fine mesh and wide front edge, the oversized net efficiently scoops up everything from leaves to tiny insects. While the plastic frame and aluminum pole don’t feel heavy-duty, they’re lightweight, easy to maneuver, and won’t damage pool liners. It’s a particularly good choice for casual users who want a space-saving, no-fuss tool that gets the job done without overcomplicating things. For shoppers who only need to skim a few times a week or want something compact for smaller setups, this skimmer offers impressive functionality for the price. **Get the PoolWhale pool skimmer on** [**Amazon**]() **or** [**Walmart**]()**.** **Our Ratings** | **Functionality** | **4.8/5** | **Maneuverability** | **4.8/5** | **Ergonomics** | **5/5** | **Build Quality** | **5/5** | **Value** | **5/5** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | The Intex Deluxe Pool Cleaning Maintenance Kit is a well-rounded, all-in-one cleaning solution from one of the most trusted names in the above-ground pool industry. This comprehensive set includes a deep skimmer net, scrub brush, vacuum attachment, and a sturdy telescopic pole that extends up to 110 inches, making it easy to tackle just about any pool-cleaning task. While it’s designed for above-ground pools, many of the attachments can work just as well in inground pools. In testing, the pole stood out as one of the best we tried—solid, comfortable to hold, and thicker than most. The plastic cleaning heads feel a notch above the flimsier ones found in lower-priced kits, and the deep skimmer net is well-molded for scooping debris from both the surface and pool floor. It’s a great option for anyone who wants a versatile tool set without having to choose multiple accessories separately. Just note that the vacuum attachment requires an 800 GPH filter pump to function, and the hose connection can be a bit finicky. Still, for those with compatible setups, this kit delivers excellent value and convenience. **Get the Intex pool skimmer at** [**Amazon**]()**.** **Our Ratings** | **Functionality** | **4.8/5** | **Build Quality** | **5/5** | **Value** | **5/5** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | Ready to ditch manual skimming altogether? The Betta SE Solar-Powered Robotic Pool Skimmer is a top-tier option that delivers near-effortless performance. Unlike traditional nets or handheld skimmers, this fully autonomous device glides across the water’s surface, collecting leaves, bugs, and other floating debris into the pool skimmer basket—all without the pool owner lifting a finger. Setup couldn’t be easier: Just turn it on, drop it into the pool, and let it get to work. Powered by a built-in solar panel, the Betta SE runs continuously in sunny conditions without needing to be recharged or plugged in. During testing, it was the fastest robotic model we tried, and its ultrasonic navigation kept it moving smoothly without getting stuck on pool edges. The generously-sized debris basket is easy to remove and empty, and its corrosion-resistant build means it’s safe to use in both chlorine and saltwater pools. The included remote control is a nice touch for manual steering when needed, too. (It’s especially helpful for targeting big debris clusters.) ![Robotic pool skimmer in use in pool Betta SE]() *Photo: Paul Rankin for BobVila.com* While it is one of the more expensive skimmers on the market, the Betta SE stands out as the most hands-off solution available. Those looking to eliminate the hassle of daily skimming will find that this robot earns its keep. **What our tester says:** "This skimmer was hands-down the fastest robot skimmer I’ve tested—just turn it on, toss it in, and watch it go to work."—Paul Rankin, Product Reviews tester and writer **Get the Betta pool skimmer robot at** [**Amazon**]() **or** [**Betta**]()**.** **Our Ratings** | **Functionality** | **4.7/5** | **Maneuverability** | **5/5** | **Ergonomics** | **4/5** | **Build Quality** | **4.5/5** | **Value** | **4.3/5** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | For those looking for a sturdy, large-capacity pool net without splurging on a premium model, the PoolWhale Pool Skimmer Net Rake strikes an excellent balance between performance and cost. With a wide 17" opening and a deep 14.5" mesh net, it’s designed to collect a large volume of leaves, twigs, and other floating debris, making it ideal for pools surrounded by trees as well as for anyone dealing with frequent surface clutter. This skimmer net impressed us with its build quality for the price. The frame features a thick aluminum interior wrapped in durable plastic, offering better support and toughness than cheaper all-plastic options. The nylon mesh feels strong and resists tearing, and the medium mesh size does a good job of collecting leaves and bugs without frequent clogging. It doesn’t come with a pole, but the handle features easy-to-use clip buttons and fits standard 1¼" telescopic poles. While it’s not quite as heavy-duty as our Best Overall pick from ProTuff, it comes close and costs about half the price. For pool owners who want a reliable, high-volume skimmer that won’t break the bank, this model is well worth considering. **Get the PoolWhale pool skimmer net rake at** [**Amazon**]()**.** **Our Ratings** | **Functionality** | **4.2/5** | **Maneuverability** | **5/5** | **Ergonomics** | **4/5** | **Build Quality** | **3.8/5** | **Value** | **4.7/5** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | This pool leaf skimmer from Sunnyglade is a no-frills, budget-friendly skimmer that works well for light, everyday cleaning tasks. Made from lightweight plastic with a fine mesh net, its easy maneuverability makes it ideal for scooping out leaves, insects, and other small debris from pools, hot tubs, fountains, and even koi ponds. It attaches easily to a standard telescopic pole (not included) with a simple push-button connection. During testing, we found this skimmer to be best suited for quick cleanups. The shallow net doesn’t hold as much as deeper models, so it’s not ideal for collecting large amounts of debris, but it’s perfectly adequate for grabbing a few floating leaves or bugs. The plastic frame and mesh feel relatively thin compared to heavier-duty options, so it may not hold up to heavy use season after season, but at this price point, that’s to be expected. Overall, the Sunnyglade is a solid pick for pool owners who need a lightweight, affordable skimmer for quick maintenance—not a heavy-duty workhorse. **Get the Sunnyglade pool skimmer at** [**Amazon**]()**.** #### Our Ratings | **Functionality** | **5/5** | **Maneuverability** | **4/5** | **Ergonomics** | **5/5** | **Build Quality** | **5/5** | **Value** | **5/5** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | The SkimmerMotion pool cleaner offers a clever way to keep the pool surface clean without relying on manual nets or solar-powered robots. This compact floating skimmer attaches directly to an existing pool vacuum hose setup and uses the pump’s suction to follow the vacuum around the pool. As it moves, it creates a whirlpool effect that draws in leaves, bugs, and other floating debris. Installation is refreshingly simple. It easily connects to most vacuum systems and starts working right away, provided the pool pump is rated at 1 horsepower or higher. During testing, we found it particularly effective at removing smaller debris, such as tiny leaves and surface scum. However, larger pieces of debris (over 1 inch wide) won’t pass through the intake opening, and overall suction performance may vary depending on the strength of the pump. While it’s a convenient set-it-and-forget-it tool, the lightweight floating components may not hold up to frequent rough handling. Still, for those looking for a hands-free solution that can boost surface cleaning efforts alongside the existing vacuum, this automatic skimmer is a handy add-on. **Get the SkimmerMotion pool skimmer at** [**Amazon**]()**.** #### Our Ratings | **Functionality** | **5/5** | **Maneuverability** | **4.5/5** | **Ergonomics** | **4.8/5** | **Build Quality** | **3.8/5** | **Value** | **5/5** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | The Poolaza Handheld Skimmer is a compact, no-fuss option that’s ideal for hot tubs, spas, kiddie pools, and quick surface cleanups. With an ultra-fine mesh net and a short aluminum handle, this skimmer is designed for close-range use—perfect for scooping out leaves, bugs, and even tiny particles like pollen or dust. While the construction is relatively lightweight, the reinforced frame and fine nylon mesh feel surprisingly sturdy for a tool typically priced under $20. In testing, it proved effective for grabbing small debris in tight spaces where a long-handled net would be overkill. It’s also easy to maneuver and won’t scratch or damage vinyl pool liners, thanks to its smooth plastic frame. That said, it’s not meant for deep pools or heavy-duty use. The short handle limits reach, and long-term durability will depend on how well it’s cared for. Leaving it in the sun between uses may cause premature wear. But as an affordable, reliable skimmer for or smaller setups, this gets light-duty jobs done with ease. **Get the Poolaza pool skimmer at** [**Amazon**]()**.** ## [Jump to Our Top Picks](<#recap>) - ![Intex pool cleaning kit skimmer in pool]() *Photo: Paul Rankin for BobVila.com* - ![SkimmerMotion]() *Photo: Paul Rankin for BobVila.com* - ![PoolWhale telescopic skimmer 01]() *Photo: Paul Rankin for BobVila.com* - ![ProTuff skimmer]() *Photo: Paul Rankin for BobVila.com* - ![Poolwhale Net Rake]() *Photo: Paul Rankin for BobVila.com* [][][] ## How We Tested the Best Pool Skimmers To find the best pool skimmers across different styles and price points, we evaluated more than two dozen models from top manufacturers, including both manual and automatic options. Each product was tested for ease of use, durability, build quality, debris collection performance, and overall value. For robotic and automatic models, we also considered setup time, navigation, battery life (or solar performance), and how well they integrated with existing pool systems. For manual skimmers, we focused on net depth, mesh quality, frame sturdiness, and comfort during use. We used each skimmer in a real backyard pool in Florida, rating each based on how effectively it removed leaves, bugs, and fine debris. We also factored in price, expected longevity, and customer support where applicable. To round out our testing, we read dozens of user reviews to identify common complaints and standout features not immediately evident in short-term use. | **Product** | **Functionality** | **Maneuverability** | **Ergonomics** | **Build Quality** | **Value** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | [ProTuff Heavy Duty Fine Mesh Pool Skimmer]() | 5/5 | 5/5 | 4.5/5 | 5/5 | 4/5 | | [PoolWhale Upgrades Telescopic Pool Skimmer]() | 4.8/5 | 5/5 | 4/5 | 3.8/5 | 4.5/5 | | [Intex Deluxe Pool Cleaning Maintenance Kit]() | 4.8/5 | 4.8/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 | | [Betta SE Solar-Powered Smart Robotic Pool Skimmer]() | 4.8/5 | Not applicable | Not applicable | 5/5 | 5/5 | | [PoolWhale Pool Skimmer Net Rake]() | 4.7/5 | 5/5 | 4/5 | 4.5/5 | 4.3/5 | | [Sunnyglade Pool Skimming Net]() | 4.2/5 | 5/5 | 4/5 | 3.8/5 | 4.7/5 | | [SkimmerMotion Original Automatic Pool Cleaner]() | 5/5 | 4/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 | | [Poolaza Handheld Skimmer Net]() | 5/5 | 4.5/5 | 4.8/5 | 3.8/5 | 5/5 | ## What to Consider When Choosing a Pool Skimmer Before deciding on either a manual or automatic pool skimmer as a go-to [pool tool](), it’s good to be familiar with several other features that are frequently considered. It’s worth taking a few minutes to think about these factors, as they impact initial cost and how the pool skimmer will be used on a day-to-day basis. ### Type of Pool Skimmer There are two main categories of pool skimmers: manual and automatic. Choosing the type that is most appropriate will depend on both the type of pool (above-ground or inground) and how much daily effort the pool owner wants to put in. Manual and automatic pool skimmers vary in cost and complexity. In the following sections, we look at each of these aspects in more detail. #### Manual The simplest manual pool skimmer is essentially a shallow net attached to a pole. The main advantage of manual pool skimmers is price. These are the low-budget solutions, and they do a perfectly good job of fishing a few leaves out of the water. If they have drawbacks, it’s that they often can’t pick up very much, they may not be especially durable, and they always require physical effort. Lifting a net containing 20 or 30 pounds of wet leaves while leaning over a pool is not easy. There are some manual skimmers that are larger and stronger than others. There are also [pool maintenance]() kits that have skimmer heads and attachments for other pool-cleaning tasks. #### Automatic Automatic pool skimmers come in three formats: stationary, floating, and robotic. **Stationary** pool skimmers are fitted to the side of above-ground pools, and they are connected to the water pump/circulation system. Leaves and other debris fall into a skimmer basket on the outside of the pool or hooked to the inside rail so it is easy to empty. **Floating** pool skimmers are designed to be attached to [pool vacuums](). While the vacuum cleans the bottom of the pool, the floating skimmer creates a whirlpool that draws in material from the surface. **Robotic** pool skimmers run independently of the [pool pump](), and they swim across the surface, picking up floating waste as they go. A pool robot skimmer is usually a cordless, solar-powered device. While the initial investment is higher, there are no ongoing costs, and they are often environmentally friendly. ### Pool Type The type of pool that needs to be cleaned will help determine which type of skimmer to purchase. Some skimmers can be used in virtually any pool, but choosing the wrong kind could damage or destroy the pool. **Above-ground pools** can be cleaned with manual pool skimmers, though it can sometimes be awkward to reach all the way around a larger pool with a net. Standing on a movable step or platform will get the job done (just make sure it’s stable!). Alternatively, purchasing a longer telescopic pole can make a manual skimmer easier to use. Stationary pool skimmers are described as suitable for above-ground pools, but it’s important to check installation requirements. Some hang or clamp a pool filter basket on the edge, while others require a hole to be cut into the side of the pool for installation. Robotic pool skimmers work well in above-ground pools as well. While floating pool skimmers can work in above-ground pools, these skimmers need to work with [a pool vacuum](), and some robotic vacuums can damage soft-sided pools, so check the pool instructions before using these tools. **Inground pools** can be cleaned with manual skimmers, robotic skimmers, and floating skimmers, but stationary pool skimmers are not suitable for inground pools. Most inground pools have built-in skimmer inlets connected to the pool’s pump and filter, but there’s no edge to use to connect an add-on stationary skimmer. ### Maintenance and Ease of Use The majority of pool skimmers are easy to look after and require minimal maintenance. However, overlooking maintenance will usually reduce the tool’s effectiveness and shorten its useful life, so it’s worth considering basic upkeep. With **manual** pool skimmers, it’s really just a question of emptying the net. The contents can usually be added to the compost heap. Because manual skimmers are very low cost, though, they are often neglected. If left lying on the lawn, someone may eventually step on it, or moisture might get into any metal parts and cause rust. Simply standing it against a wall under cover will prevent most problems. **Stationary** pool skimmers are mostly made from strong plastic and, beyond emptying the basket and occasionally wiping it with a damp cloth, they are usually maintenance-free. Floating pool skimmers collect waste in the attached vacuum, requiring minimal maintenance of their own. [**Robotic** skimmers]() have an internal collecting tray that needs to be emptied. Solar panels are less effective if dusty, so wiping them off regularly will make them more effective. ### Capacity The capacity of a particular pool skimmer will affect how much debris can be collected and how often it needs to be emptied. - Net size is usually the determining factor on manual pool skimmers, and some have a weight rating. - Above-ground pool skimmers have a collecting basket, so check the size of the basket before ordering. - With floating pool skimmers, it’s the vacuum that determines how much can be collected. - Robot pool skimmers have an internal tray, so check the size of the tray before purchasing. The amount of debris collected will determine how frequently the collection tray needs to be emptied. If the pool is in an open area, for example, it will gather fewer leaves than a pool with shade trees nearby. With most pool skimmers, it is best to empty the device as soon as the job is finished, or waste can start to rot inside the net or tray. While stationary models with collecting baskets are the exception, clearing them regularly is still a good idea. ## FAQs There is a lot to consider when searching for a new pool skimmer to keep a backyard swimming pool clean, and you may have a few lingering questions. Below are answers to some frequently asked questions. ## Meet the Tester Paul Rankin is a product reviewer and DIY enthusiast who’s tested dozens of pool tools firsthand. His reviews focus on real-world performance, value, and ease of use. *Additional research provided by Bob Beacham.* ## Author Bob Beacham is an engineer by trade and has spent 35 years working on everything from auto parts to oil rigs. He is also an avid DIY enthusiast. Bob started writing for the BobVila.com team in 2020 and covers tools, outdoor equipment, and home improvement projects.