We need a professional opinion to a dilemma. Our bedroom ceiling leaked for years. The rain comes through a couple of spots on the ceiling and also down through a partial wall that is shared by a closet.
The roof has a 4’ wide flat area that runs the length of the house. The problem part of the bedroom is under this flat area, however, so are other rooms in the house, and they don’t leak.
A lot of pine needles collect on the far east AND west sides of the roof. The roofer was aware of this when we hired him 2 years ago.
The new roof just started to leak in the same places. The guy says it’s due to the pine needles. He removed the debris, and says it's all fixed. (We asked him why the pine needles at the other end of the house don’t cause the roof to leak; he didn’t have an answer.)
We don’t want to wait to see if he’s right, because we’ve since learned that he’s an unlicensed con man. He’s been sued by the guy whose license he stole. He’s facing jail time if he gets caught again, but only if it’s for a job he did AFTER the court case. We’re unsure if we’re before or after. He’s scared and is willing to fix our problem at his expense. He doesn’t know we know. We want him to pay someone else to do the work, but because he says it’s fixed now, we’re in the position of waiting for it to rain, and then threatening to report him if he doesn’t make good.
We’d like to know how this might play out. Is it really possible for rain-soaked pine needles to cause a leak in a new roof? If so, could a real roofer have prevented it? Is it plausible that it leaked at one end of the house and not the other? Could his clearing the debris fix a leaky roof? Thank you for any answers you might provide!
- 15 Old House Features We Shouldn't Abandon
- 17 Tiny Bathrooms We Love
- 30 Things Everyone Should Know
- 21 Expert Choices for Fail-Safe Paint Colors
- 20 Easy 60-Minute Home Improvements
- 10 IKEA Favorites Made New with Paint
- The Tiniest Appliances You Never Knew Existed
- 133 Smart Storage Ideas for the Whole House
- 16 New Ways to Store Kitchen Necessities
- 8 Ways to Make a Small Room Look Big
- Sweet Dreams: 15 Inventive Beds You Can Make Yourself
- 10 Fall Door DIYs for the Best House on the Block
- The Cheapest Ways to Boost Home Value
- 10 New Uses for Old Doors
- 26 Easy Painted Pumpkins for Halloween
- 15 Once-Popular Home Items Now Vanishing
- 8 Unique Ways to Build Your Own Table
- Woodworking for Beginners: 10 Projects
- 7 Reasons to Reconsider Wallpaper
- 10 New Uses for Old Dressers
- 7 Upgrades You Can Do in Under 300 Seconds
- 10 Thrifty DIY Ways to Organize Your Home
- 12 "Different" Ways to Store Firewood
- 5 DIY Farm Table Projects That Will Last a Lifetime
- Beyond White: 11 Bathroom Paint Colors
- 10 DIYs for a Festive Front Door This Fall
- 10 Creative New Ways to Use Old Bottles
- The 10 Best Things to Buy Secondhand
- 16 Must-See Coffee Tables You Can DIY—Easily!