The Best Wood Stain, According to Handy Homeowners and DIYers

Choose the right stain to enhance all your wood, inside and out.

The Best Wood Stain for Furniture, Cabinets, Trim, and More

Photo: istockphoto.com

Wood stain is a paint-like product comprised of colorant dissolved or suspended in a solvent or other medium. It’s used to enrich the look of wood, bringing out the natural grain and adding depth and color; usually, a stain is employed to darken light varieties like pine, making them resemble deeper-toned woods, such as walnut or cherry. Whether you’re staining a bookcase or aiming to match the color of new wood cabinets to the trim in your kitchen, choosing the right stain can help make the project a masterpiece. Keep reading to learn what to look for when shopping for wood stain, and to find out why we chose the following five formulas as best for specific projects.

  1. BEST WATER-BASED STAIN: SamaN Wood Stain
  2. BEST OIL-BASED STAIN: Watco Danish Oil Wood Finish
  3. BEST VARNISH STAIN: Minwax Polyshades Stain & Polyurethane
  4. BEST GEL STAIN: Minwax Gel Stain
  5. BEST EXTERIOR STAIN: Ready Seal Wood Stain and Sealer


The Best Wood Stain for Furniture, Cabinets, Trim, Floors, and More

Photo: istockphoto.com

Key Considerations for Choosing a Wood Stain

Understand the Formulations

Before buying a stain, understand the properties of the four different formulas available.

Oil-Based Stain: Because it contains oil, this stain naturally repels water to a degree, making it a good choice for wood that might get wet, such as a kitchen tabletop. Oil-based stain also contains solvents with volatile organic chemicals (VOCs), which help the oil and pigments to blend, but can also create noxious fumes, so only use oil-based stain in well-ventilated areas. Depending on the brand, oil stain can take up to two days to dry sufficiently before a finish coat, such as clear polyurethane or varnish, can be applied.

While oil stain is found in both indoor and outdoor products, it can only be applied in temperatures between 50° F and 80° Fahrenheit. At lower temps, it can become thick and unworkable, and at higher temps, especially in high humidity, the stain tends to “sweat” and leave blotches on the surface. Oil-based stain can be applied by spraying or brushing, and cleaning the tools afterward requires the use of a solvent, such as turpentine or mineral spirits.

Water-Based Stain: Comprised largely of pigment and water—and sometimes a small amount of solvent—water-based stains are free of or low in VOCs and less likely to create toxic fumes during application. Water-based stain usually dries quickly, often within a few hours, and is usually used on interior projects, such as hardwood floors and trim. The downside to water-based stain is that the water content raises the grain of the wood; be sure to sand the surface to get rid of roughness before applying a final coat of sealer. Water-based stains can be applied by brushing or spraying, and tools clean up easily with plain soap and water.

Varnish Stain: Varnish stain, a formula found in some interior stain products and the majority of exterior stain products, is a combination of oil-based wood stain and surface sealer. A two-in-one, time-saving product, it contains oil, solvents, pigments, and resins, which both dye the wood grain and also form a hardened protective coating. Because they contain solvents, varnish stains are often high in VOCs and should be used only in well-ventilated areas.

While varnish stain can be applied by brushing or spraying, brushing offers a smoother finish best suited to interior projects. Any tiny bubbles caused by spraying will barely be noticeable on large exterior surfaces. Whatever application technique you choose, be sure to coat the surface carefully and uniformly to avoid blotchiness and color discrepancies. Cleaning tools afterward requires a solvent, such as turpentine or mineral spirits.

Gel Stain: Though oil-based, gel stains aren’t as messy as regular oil- and water-based stains, because the gel won’t drip, splatter, or run. The gel is created by whipping oil, solvents, and pigments to produce a thick, smooth consistency that won’t separate. As with other oil-based stains, you must have adequate ventilation when applying with a brush (the formula is too thick for a spray), only apply at temperatures between 50° and 80° Fahrenheit, and use turpentine or mineral spirits for cleanup.

Consider Opacity and Protection in Exterior Stains 

Most interior wood stain products are designed to impart a transparent dye that will not obscure the grain of the wood. Exterior stains, such as deck and fence stain, however, often contain higher amounts of pigment, which serve to conceal some or most of the grain. When buying exterior stain, check the opacity on the label to get the look you desire.

  • Toner—contains just a hint of pigment so the natural wood grain is visible.
  • Semi-transparent—adds a rich color but the grain is still fairly visible.
  • Semi-opaque—imparts deep color and obscures most of the wood grain.
  • Opaque—similar to paint. Completely covers the grain with dense color.

Also, because exterior wood must bear the brunt of harsh UV rays and whatever else Mother Nature dishes out, make sure the product you purchase for a deck or fence contains UV protection and mildew protection. (If staining an exterior project, check out our guide to the best deck stain for additional info.)

The Best Wood Stains

Best Wood Stain (Water-Based): SamaN

Photo: amazon.com

1. BEST WATER-BASED STAIN: SamaN Wood Stain ($12.67 per 12 ounces)

A low VOC stain, SamaN’s Wood Stain is ideal for all types of interior wood projects, such as trim, cabinets, and doors. One 12-ounce bottle covers up to 75 square feet and dries in as little as two hours. It’s available in 42 shades, including Canadian Maple, Spice, and Paprika, and can be brushed or sprayed on. Amazon buyers say applying the stain is “foolproof,” awarding it an enthusiastic 4.5 out of five stars for great looking color and easy application. Cleanup is with plain soap and water. Available from Amazon.



Best Wood Stain (Oil-Based): Watco

Photo: amazon.com

2. BEST OIL-BASED STAIN: Watco Danish Oil Wood Finish ($8.98 per pint)

For rich, luxurious wood tones, Watco’s Danish Oil Wood Finish is an excellent interior stain available in 14 colors, including Walnut, Golden Oak, and Fruitwood. It can be applied by brushing or spraying (a pint covers up to 85 square feet) and dries in about six hours. Applying additional coats will increase the depth of color and sheen. Amazon buyers award the oil-based stain 4.5 stars for gorgeous color and imparting a hand-rubbed look. Cleanup requires a solvent, such as mineral spirits. Available from Amazon.



Best Wood Stain (Varnish): Minwax PolyShades

Photo: amazon.com

3. BEST VARNISH STAIN: Minwax Polyshades Stain & Polyurethane ($28.36 per quart)

An interior stain/varnish combo, Minwax Polyshades Stain & Polyurethane comes in 14 colors—including royal walnut, Tudor, and mission oak—and satin or gloss finish. One quart covers up to 150 square feet, and while a single coat dries in about six hours, two coats are recommended for the richest color and sheen. For a flawless finish, be sure to apply Polyshades with a high-quality brush. Amazon buyers award Polyshades a hearty 4.4 stars, saying it imparts a “beautiful finish” and creates a “durable surface.” Cleanup requires a solvent, such as mineral spirits. Available from Amazon.



Best Wood Stain (Gel): Minwax

Photo: amazon.com

4. BEST GEL STAIN: Minwax Gel Stain ($19.70 per quart)

No worries about drips and runs—even when staining vertical surfaces—with Minwax Gel Stain. It provides uniform color in 12 shades, including chestnut, coffee, and hickory, and can be used on either interior or exterior wood (though exterior surfaces must be coated with a protective finish, such as spar varnish). Apply with a brush, cloth, or foam applicator (the quart size covers up to 200 square feet); it can be recoated in 10 hours and dries completely in 24 hours. Amazon buyers award this gel stain 4.4 stars for its rich color and no-mess application. A solvent is necessary for cleanup. Available from Amazon.



Best Wood Stain for Exteriors: Ready Seal

Photo: amazon.com

5. BEST EXTERIOR STAIN: Ready Seal Wood Stain and Sealer ($149 for five gallons)

For great looking decks, fences, and outdoor furniture, check out double-duty Ready Seal Wood Stain and Sealer. One gallon of this stain-and-sealer combo covers up to 125 square feet on most exterior types of wood, such as cedar and spruce. This semi-transparent exterior stain may be applied with a brush, a roller, or a sprayer. Two light coats are recommended, and the product can be recoated in as little as 45 minutes; the final coat will dry completely after 72 hours, so plan not to walk on a newly stained deck. The product protects the wood from UV rays and reduces the risk of mold and mildew growth. Amazon buyers give Ready Seal 4.4 stars, calling it the “best deck stain available” and saying they will “never use another brand.” Cleanup requires a solvent, such as mineral spirits. Available from Amazon.