We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs. Learn More ›
Patio heaters range from cafe-table units to showpiece towers and fire-pit hybrids—but how much do you really need to spend to stay comfortable on chilly nights? For this Spend Smart test, we tried out three top-rated patio heaters across three different price tiers under the same conditions: cool fall evenings, light breeze, and repeated warm-up cycles. Here’s how a tabletop, a tower, and a fire-pit heater stack up. (Note: Prices are current at publication.)
Patio Heaters Comparison
| Tier | Model | Price | Max Output | Heat Radius | Wind Resilience |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Budget | Cuisinart Portable Tabletop Patio Heater | $100 | 11,000 BTU | 3–4 ft | N/A (small flame, close-range) |
| Mid-Range | Pamapic Propane Patio Heater | $240 | 41,000 BTU | 6–8 ft | Strong (glass enclosure kept flame lit) |
| Premium | Ninja Fireside360 Outdoor Heater & FirePit | $500 | 80,000 BTU | 10–12 ft | Moderate (can be affected by strong wind) |
Our Testing Methods
Testing took place outdoors in the high-40s to low-50s degrees Fahrenheit. We timed warm-up to “comfortable at approximately 6 feet,” noted heat radius at 3, 5, 8, 10, and 12 feet, observed wind resilience (flame stability/heat loss), and logged usability (assembly, ignition reliability, mobility, and safety features). Where relevant, we cited prior hands-on results from our full guide to the best patio heaters.
Budget
Photo: Amazon
What We Like
- Ultra-portable
- Tip-over shut-off
- Works great at a table for 2 people
- Quick setup
What We Don’t Like
- Limited range of 3 to 4 feet
- Not a space heater for a group
Ideal for compact patios, balconies, or two-person seating setups. This portable heater delivers cozy warmth in close range and sets up in seconds.
Bottom line: The perfect balcony/café companion. Don’t expect it to warm a full seating area.
Mid-Range
Photo: Amazon
What We Like
- Adjustable flame and striking ambiance
- Stays lit in breezes
- Easy ignition
- Locking wheels
- Cover included
What We Don’t Like
- Glass gets very hot
- Overall heat is less than big tower/fire pit units
Designed for small patios or dining areas, this tower-style heater balances heat output and aesthetics. The glass flame enclosure keeps it burning bright even in breezy conditions while adding a striking focal point to your space.
Bottom line: The sweet spot for most patios—good warmth plus showpiece flame without premium pricing.
Premium
Photo: Amazon
What We Like
- Up to 80,000 BTU of 360-degree heat
- Smokeless performance
- Heat or flame-only modes
- 10-to-12-feet comfortable circle of warmth
- Stylish entertainer’s centerpiece
What We Don’t Like
- Heavier
- Performs best in semi-sheltered areas (wind can reduce comfort radius)
This hybrid heater-fire pit delivers serious heat with 360-degree coverage and a clean, smokeless flame. It doubles as an outdoor centerpiece—ideal for hosts who want warmth, ambiance, and performance in one high-end unit.
Bottom line: If you host regularly or want a unit that’s both a heater and a fire-pit, this earns the splurge.
Head-to-Head Verdict
- Budget: Great at arm’s length; stalls beyond approximately 4 feet.
- Mid-Range: Best balance—real warmth for a small group plus excellent wind resilience.
- Premium: Biggest, most even heat, and best multi-purpose experience for entertaining.
Our Recommendation: Spend smart. Go mid-range for most patios; go premium if you frequently host 4 to 8 guests or want a combined heater-plus-fire-pit showpiece.
Where to Buy the Tested Patio Heaters
Budget
Cuisinart Portable Tabletop Patio Heater
Mid-range
Pamapic 41,000 BTU Wheeled Propane Patio Heater
Premium
Ninja Fireside360 Outdoor Heater & Fire Pit
