The Dean of Home Renovation & Repair Advice

COMMUNITY FORUM

jamesd1253

12:20PM | 08/30/05
Member Since: 08/29/05
1 lifetime posts
Bvelectrical
Recently a residents compressor failed in a mobile home park that I manage.

Ultimately, the electrican found the pedistal suppling power to the home had a Zinsco breaker. The buss bar and breaker had to be replaced.

The mobile home owner now says we are responsible for the replacement of the compressor.

Can the failure of the breaker cause the compressor to burn out?

Tom O

03:18PM | 08/30/05
Member Since: 09/17/02
487 lifetime posts
.Since you didn't say why the breaker & buss bars were replaced I'll guess that the breaker failed due to loose connections (breaker/buss bars burned). if that was in fact the case, then the home was likely receiving low voltage, which is really hard on motors.

Tom

Billhart

05:25PM | 08/30/05
Member Since: 04/25/05
1918 lifetime posts
The compressor might have failed and caused it to draw excessive current.

And the Zinsco breaker might have failed to trip and that exess current damaged the bus bars.


tshea1

04:08PM | 08/31/05
Member Since: 05/03/05
79 lifetime posts
quote: Can the failure of the breaker cause the compressor to burn out?

Maybe!

Inversely, the compressor can cause the breaker to burn out!

My suspicions are the compressor failed, thus taking out the breaker and the bus.


Tom O

01:46PM | 09/01/05
Member Since: 09/17/02
487 lifetime posts
Not to cause an arguement, but I've dealt with Zinsco in the past & they are just a cut above FPE & I would lean towards the breaker being the cause of the trouble. Coupled with it being outdoors, where many inferior breakers bite the dust, I'd vote for the breaker being the cause.

However, since we don't have the smoking & glowing parts to examine, and there is a potential here for some hard feelings between the tennant & landlord, maybe there should be some friendly negotiation between the two in order to avoid a trip to court. If that happens, the lawyers will make more than the cost of the compressor & breaker combined.

Tom


Post a reply as Anonymous

Photo must be in JPG, GIF or PNG format and less than 5MB.

Reply_choose_button

captcha
type the code from the image

Anonymous

Post_new_button or Login_button
Register

Follow Us

horizontal divider
facebook
 
webapp2