The Organic Mattress: My “Green” Nursery Challenge

By Jessica Provenz | Updated Sep 16, 2020 7:18 PM

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs.

jprovenz organic baby mattress green nursery challenge“You will never sleep again!” is something that people love to say to expecting parents.  But, I decided my baby (and therefore my husband and I) would sleep happily, comfortably, and safely.  On what, was the question.

My first nursery purchase was the ever-practical crib mattress.  After reading a mattress article in The New York Times about harmful flame-retardant chemicals like PBDE’s (which have been found in breast milk), I knew that I wanted an organic mattress; one that was VOC-free and used natural flame retardants like cotton, wool, and natural latex.

At one national mattress retailer, their “organic” crib mattress had only 20% organic material—soy—the rest was memory foam with potentially toxic VOCs!  Perhaps the way to go was the smaller, mom-and-pop shops.  Of the indie sellers I located, none were within driving distance from our Jersey digs.  I certainly wanted to test the mattresses in person (isn’t that half the fun?).  And, if I didn’t pick a comfy mattress, I felt certain that our future soccer player would complain about it…at 4 a.m.!

Just as I was about to throw in the towel and order online, an organic mattress store—Essentia—opened that very week, just 1 hour away (talk about good karma).  I went to the store and lay on their stock. Luxurious.  Plush.  And, on sale for their grand opening – yippee!

I went with the top-of-the-line crib mattress ($579 reduced to $479).  Expensive, but this was my first nursery purchase and nothing seemed too extravagant for baby (yet).  The salesman had undergone three months of education on all things organic and I was his guinea pig.  I went hog-wild and bought a king-sized mattress for myself with pillows (pictured below).  And, since I’d spent two hours listening to his rap—and spending a hefty sum, he threw in a mattress protector for baby ($120 value).

Jprovenz organic mattress green nursery challenge

Two words on organic mattresses: “not cheap!”  A crib mattress will run between $175-$600; a king-sized bed between $2,000-$6,000.  Since we spend a third of our lives on mattresses (baby spends half), I reasoned it’s not something to skimp on.  For a cheaper option, consider an organic futon mattress for yourself.

Tips on Buying Organic Mattresses:

– Most sellers offer a satisfaction refund or exchange program – helpful, if you can’t travel to test in person

– “Eco-friendly,” “green,” “environmental” are promo words – they do not mean organic

– Ask what’s in the mattress.  Layer by layer.  Make sure it does NOT contain: latex memory foam (get a natural latex), coils or springs, or polyester fill.

– Most sellers deliver free-of-charge and offer a 20+ year warranty.

Where To Buy an Organic Crib Mattress:

Essentia Organic Mattresses (offers readers of this site a 10% discount on all products through 9/31/11.  Passcode: BOBVILA)

The Organic Mattress Store

The Natural Sleep Store

Satara Baby

Healthy Choice Organic Mattresses

Week 1 of My “Green” Nursery Challenge was a pricey one!  I dropped $479 on a crib mattress and protector (pictured) – reduced from $699 – leaving 7 weeks and $1521 to create the dream nursery.

More importantly, months later baby is sleeping safely and soundly… and so are his parents!