The Best Cookie Cutters for Baking

Whether you're gearing up for a holiday party or looking for a fun activity to do with your family, a great set of cookie cutters can make all the difference in your baking. 

BobVila.com and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.

Best Cookie Cutters

Photo: amazon.com

You don’t have to bake professionally to enjoy a high-quality set of cookie cutters. This versatile and long-time favorite kitchen tool can help you form the perfect cookie shape no matter what occasion you’re celebrating. While cookie cutters are most often used around the holiday season, they come in many different shapes and sizes. In this guide, explore a roundup of the best cookie cutters for baking, whatever the occasion.

  1. BEST OVERALL: Ateco Plain Edge Round Cutters in Graduated Sizes
  2. BEST BUDGET: Wilton Cookie Cutters Set, 101-Piece
  3. BEST FOR VERSATILITY: K&S Artisan Round Cookie Biscuit Cutter Set
  4. BEST INDESTRUCTIBLE: KSPOWWIN 5 Pieces Stainless Steel Cookie Cutters
  5. BEST 3D: ULEE 3D Christmas Cookie Cutters Set – 8 Piece
  6. BEST FOR KIDS: stbeyond Stainless Steel Sandwiches Cutter Set
Best Cookie Cutters

Photo: amazon.com

Choosing the best cookie cutter will depend almost entirely on what kind of shape you want to bake your cookies into. However, there are a few other factors to consider before you purchase your next set. Everything from the cookie-cutter material itself to how easy it is to store can impact which set you choose to add to your kitchen.

Material

Cookie cutters come in four different kinds of materials: plastic, stainless steel, copper, and aluminum. Plastic and aluminum cookie cutters are the most inexpensive type, and they’re easy to remove from the dough. They often have a duller edge, making them the safest option to use with young kids. However, they are more likely to break and quicker to lose their shape than other materials.

Copper and stainless steel cookie cutters are more heavy-duty, will better retain their shape over time, and are better for cutting shapes with smaller details. However, they are more expensive than plastic and aluminum cutters. Stainless steel cookie cutters are also prone to rust.

Themes

Another thing to consider when choosing your next set of cookie cutters is the cookie cutter theme. For a seasonal treat, there are shapes that coincide with most holidays, like Santa Claus-shaped cookies for Christmas, heart-shaped cookies for Valentine’s Day, or football-shaped cookies for Super Bowl Sunday.

When baking and decorating cookies that are not tied to a specific season or themed event, there are simple circle-shaped cutters. Those could also be used for holiday events, as they can be decorated to match any theme. Similar to a cookie cutter, a cookie press is another tool used to create consistently shaped cookies.

Storage

It’s important to consider the storage capability of cookie cutters. Most cookie-cutter sets are small and portable. However, some styles are bulkier and will require more room to store. Sets that don’t offer a storage component can make for some messy and disorganized drawers.

Some sets are designed so that the smaller cutters stack inside the larger ones, which makes them easier to stash away. Other sets even come with a small carrying case, which can help you easily transport your cutters to any event. Before choosing your next set, take stock of the available room in your kitchen.

Our Top Picks

The best cookie cutters can easily cut through sticky dough and create perfectly shaped cookies. While they’re available in various shapes and sizes, top-quality cookie cutters are also versatile and can be used with other types of food.

The recommendations below are based on a range of categories to help you find the cookie- cutter set you need for your kitchen.

Best Overall

The Best Cookie Cutters Options Ateco
Photo: amazon.com

The Ateco Plain Edge Round Cutters are one of the top-rated cookie cutter sets on the market. Made from stainless steel, these professional-grade, heavy-duty cutters make clean cuts without leaving rough edges behind. They are also designed with rolled edges on the top to prevent finger injuries while  cutting.

This set comes with 11 different sizes—ranging from ¾ inches to 3⅝ inches—which easily fit inside a tin box to make for easy storage. These cookie cutters come in a single shape— round—and are dishwasher safe.

Best Budget

The Best Cookie Cutters Options Wilton
Photo: amazon.com

The Wilton Cookie Cutters set comes with 101 different shapes. These colorful plastic cookie cutters are each 3½ inches by 3½ inches and are designed with a ⅓-inch-thick comfort edge to prevent finger injuries. The deep blade on the bottom makes it easy to cut out not only cookies but also sandwiches and other kinds of food.

The shapes come in everything from gingerbread men to circles to airplanes to letters to dinosaurs. They’re one of the lowest-priced options on the market with this many different cutters, and they’re dishwasher safe. The downside is that they’re made of plastic, so they may become flimsy over time.

Best For Versatility

The Best Cookie Cutters Options KS
Photo: amazon.com

The K&S Artisan Round Cookie Biscuit Cutter Set comes with 11 different-size circle cutters that provide a crisp, clean edge for cookies, sandwiches, canapes, mini-cakes, mini-pies, scones, doughnuts, fondant, and biscuits. Made with 100 percent commercial-grade stainless steel, these cutters are rust-proof as well as dishwasher safe. They also come with rolled edges to protect fingers while cutting.

In addition to being great for cutting cookies, this set also comes with four cookie stencils to create playful and creative designs, and it includes a book of baking recipes. These cutters can also be used on fruit, meat, and even clay.

Best Indestructible

The Best Cookie Cutters Options Kspowwin
Photo: amazon.com

KSPOWWIN cookie cutters are made out of heavy-duty 304 stainless steel, which is one of the most durable types of stainless steel out there thanks to its resistance to corrosion and rust. Plus, they’re designed with a rolled top edge to protect fingers and make the cutters more comfortable to use.

The KSPOWWIN cookie cutter set comes with five circle-shaped cutters in the following sizes: 3.3-inch, 2.9-inch, 2.5-inch, 2-inch, and 1.7-inch. They nest within each other to make for easy storage, and they’re dishwasher safe, which makes for easy cleanup. These cutters can be used not only for cookies but also for fondant, soft fruits, craft clay, sandwiches, cheeses, and bread.

Best 3D

The Best Cookie Cutters Options Ulee
Photo: amazon.com

While everyone loves a traditional flat cookie, 3D cookies have become an increasingly popular option for those looking to add a little flair to their baking. The ULEE 3D Christmas Cookie Cutters Set comes with eight holiday-themed pieces, including a Christmas tree, snowman, deer, and sled.

Made out of premium stainless steel, these cutters are durable, long-lasting, and easy to clean. However, they are not dishwasher safe and have to be hand cleaned with hot water and soap. Still, these 3D cookie cutters make great gifts and are fun to use with the family.

Best For Kids

The Best Cookie Cutters Options stbeyond
Photo: amazon.com

The stbeyond cookie cutter set is technically used for cutting fun shapes into sandwiches, but these tools can easily be used for cookies as well as cake, pancakes, ham, rice, Jell-O, and cheese. This set comes in four shapes—Mickey Mouse, heart, dinosaur, and star—in both a small and large size. The small size is 2 inches by 2 inches, and the large size is 4 inches by 4 inches. These cutters are designed with 100 percent food-safe stainless steel as well as a unique hand cover top that protects fingers.

Each cutter is 0.2 millimeters thick and is designed to maintain its shape over time. These cutters are also dishwasher safe.

Now that you’ve explored the variety of options for some of the best cookie cutters, it’s time to answer any remaining questions. Below, check out answers to a few common questions about cookie cutters to ensure you choose the right one for your baking needs.

Q. How do you care for cookie cutters?

Make sure to wash the cookie cutters after every use and keep them dry to prevent rusting.

Q. Do you cut cookies before or after baking?

Cookies should be cut before they are baked in the oven.

Q. Can you use cookie cutters to cut fruit?

Many cookie cutters can also be used to cut fruit.