The Best Cookie Presses for Homemade Treats

Looking for a simple way to make traditional sugar cookies in a variety of designs? Try a cookie press.

BobVila.com and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.

The Best Cookie Press

Photo: amazon.com

Cookie presses are a great kitchen staple, especially around the holidays. These versatile baking tools allow you to make buttery sugar cookies in a variety of creative shapes and designs like hearts, flowers, and snowmen. Cookie presses extrude dough through shaped disks, resulting in bite-size sugar cookies referred to as spritz cookies. They are available in a variety of styles, and there are plenty of cookie presses to choose from. Here are the best cookie presses for homemade treats.

  1. BEST OVERALL: OXO Good Grips Cookie Press with Stainless Disks
  2. BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK: Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press, 13-Piece
  3. BEST METAL: Norpro Deluxe Cookie Press with Icing Gun
  4. BEST ITALIAN STYLE: Fante’s Easy Cookie Press
The Best Cookie Press Option

Photo: amazon.com

When shopping for a cookie press, deciding which type to buy is one of the first decisions to make. There are two types of cookie presses to choose from: electric and manual. Learn about the pros and cons of each type.

Electric 

Electric cookie presses offer a quick and easy way to make cookies. Most electric cookie presses have cords that plug into outlets, but there are also cordless, battery-operated options. Electric cookie presses tend to be more expensive than manual cookie presses.

Manual

Manual cookie presses are more common. Like electric cookie presses, they are easy to use but may require some getting used to. Manual cookie presses can be used anywhere because they do not require power and can also be easily transported without worrying about a cord getting in the way.

When shopping for a cookie press, it’s important to consider factors such as material, handles, and accessories. Whether you are looking for a cookie press for year-round baking or just for holiday baking, there are a variety of choices to meet your baking needs. Here are some important features to consider when choosing the best cookie press.

Materials 

Metal and plastic are two common materials cookie presses are made from. Metal cookie presses are more durable, but they must be hand-washed and dried completely to avoid rusting. Plastic cookie presses are usually less expensive and some are also dishwasher safe, which makes for easy cleanup.

Handles 

Cookie presses use one of two dough-extrusion methods. When using a cookie press with a plunger handle, press down the plunger to distribute the dough. When using a cookie press with a rotating handle, rotate the handle to press out the dough. Cookie presses with rotating handles are best for people with arthritis or hand injuries because they don’t require as much strength to operate.

Dough Tube 

The dough tube is the portion of a cookie press that holds the dough. It’s usually made out of the same material as the press itself—plastic or metal. When shopping for a cookie press, pay attention to the capacity of the dough tube. Cookie presses with higher dough-tube capacity can handle a large batch of cookies in less time. Some cookie presses have clear dough tubes, which make it easy to monitor how much dough is left in the tube.

Accessories 

Many cookie presses come with convenient accessories to maximize their functionality. Some common cookie press accessories include nozzles, pipes, or icing tips that can be used for decorating cookies or cakes.

Our Top Picks

With useful functions and convenient designs, here are some of the best cookie presses for home bakers. Check out the list to find the best option for your baking style.

Best Overall

The Best Cookie Press Option: OXO Good Grips Cookie Press with Stainless Disks
Photo: amazon.com

This cookie press comes with 12 stainless-steel disks in a variety of designs including flowers, a snowflake, and a wreath. It also comes with a convenient storage case for the disks. This plastic cookie press has a manual lever and a nonslip base. The clear cylinder makes it easy to track dough levels, and it can be taken apart for efficient cleaning.

Best Bang For The Buck

The Best Cookie Press Option: Wilton Simple Success Cookie Press, 13-Piece
Photo: amazon.com

This affordable cookie press comes with 12 disks in a variety of designs including holiday and everyday patterns such as a heart, pumpkin, and Christmas tree. This manual cookie press is made out of white and clear plastic. It features a clear dough tube and an ergonomic handle with a soft-grip trigger. For best results, wash with soap and water before the first use and in between each use.

Best Metal

The Best Cookie Press Option: Norpro Deluxe Cookie Press with Icing Gun
Photo: amazon.com

This cookie press kit comes with an aluminum cookie press, 20 disks, an icing gun, and four icing tips. The aluminum die-plate disks offer a wide variety of cookie shapes, with options for small or large cookies. This cookie press should be hand-washed for best results.

Best Italian Style

The Best Cookie Press Option: Fante’s Easy Cookie Press
Photo: amazon.com

This authentic cookie press can be used to make Italian cookies, cheese straws, and other treats. It comes with five shapes that slide into place for easy cookie making. This manual cookie press features a rotating handle. It’s easy to load with dough and can be taken apart to clean in soap and water. This cookie press comes with Fante family recipes.

Here are some frequently asked questions and answers about cookie presses.

Q. What kind of a cookie press is suitable for beginners? 

Electric cookie presses are a good choice for beginners because they automatically calculate the correct amount of dough with the press of a button. They also require less exertion than manual cookie presses.

Q. What causes a cookie press to stop working?

A cookie press can stop working if you are using a nonstick surface because the dough will get stuck in the press instead of sticking to the surface to which you are extruding, such as a baking sheet.

Q. How do you clean a cookie press? 

Hand-washing is recommended for cookie presses, especially if they’re made of metal.