The Best Ice Scrapers of 2023

Clear vehicle windshields of light frost or thick ice during the cold winter months with any one of these top ice scrapers.

By Glenda Taylor and Kat Hodgins | Updated Dec 22, 2022 4:36 PM

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs.

The Best Ice Scraper Option

Photo: amazon.com

Removing frost and ice from a windshield or driveway is a straightforward task. Just grab an ice scraper and get to work, right? Well, not all scrapers offer the same results. The flimsy ones may not stand up to the ice or the grip of the hand that’s holding it. Others can leave streaks. Good-quality scrapers can include brushes, protective mitts, or even brass blades to remove ice effectively and quickly.

In this guide, we look at features that shoppers will want to consider when selecting a durable, effective ice scraper. We also offer our top picks for the best ice scrapers available.

  1. BEST OVERALL: AstroAI 27-Inch Snow Brush and Detachable Ice Scraper
  2. BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK: Snow Joe 2-in-1 Snow Broom With Ice Scraper
  3. BEST WITH BRUSH: AstroAI 3 in 1 Ice Scraper for Car Windshield
  4. BEST WITH MITT: BirdRock Home Ice Scraper Mitt for Car Windshield
  5. BEST MULTIPURPOSE: SubZero 51-Inch Ice Crusher Snow Broom and Squeegee
  6. BEST FOR GLOVE COMPARTMENT: SubZero Ice Crusher
  7. BEST FOR TRUCKS AND SUVS: BirdRock Home Snow MOOver 55-Inch Ice Scraper
  8. BEST FOR DRIVEWAYS: Bully Tools Heavy Duty Sidewalk and Ice Scraper
The Best Ice Scraper Option

Photo: amazon.com

How We Chose the Best Ice Scrapers 

Our biggest priority in naming the best ice scrapers was finding tools that remove ice and snow from a vehicle or driveway efficiently without causing damage. This meant looking at the construction and the features of snow brushes, scrapers, ice crushers, handles, and more. We assessed the design, materials, and practicality of dozens of ice scrapers currently available on the market.

Finding a scraper that made the chore a bit more pleasant was something we assessed, too. We made sure to include recommendations for ice scrapers with telescoping handles, mitt scrapers, and even one with a squeegee.

Brand reputation in the industry was a factor in the decision-making process. We wanted to include products from brands known for their quality, value, and customer service.

Lastly, we considered storage for each recommendation. Many of our selections are compact and easy to store in a car.

Our Top Picks

Any one of our top ice scrapers on this list will help with this cold-weather chore. Because ice-scraping needs vary by user, our picks include a range of types and sizes.

Best Overall

The Best Ice Scraper Option: AstroAI 27 Inch Snow Brush and Detachable Ice Scraper
Photo: amazon.com

AstroAl’s 27-inch snow brush delivers on versatility. Instead of a fixed brush on one end and a scraper on the other, this handy two-in-one tool features detachable parts so one person can scrape while the other brushes. Users may also take advantage of this feature to eliminate extra weight and bulk when working solo.

Little “knuckles” built into the blade of the 4.5-inch scraper help chip away at ice without damaging the windshield. A comfort-grip ergonomic handle facilitates the work.

Though the brush does not come with the same comfortable grip as the scraper, a built-in handle gives fingers a place to grasp while sweeping away snow. Two layers of temperature-resistant bristles that form the brush stand up to heavy use and help extend the lifespan of this handy tool.

Product Specs

  • Type: Snow brush/ice scraper
  • Length: 27 inches
  • Weight: 1.74 pounds

Pros

  • Brush and ice scraper can be used separately
  • Layered bristles on the brush
  • Ergonomic comfort grip
  • Lightweight and easy to store

Cons

  • No ergonomic grip on the brush when detached

Get the AstroAI 27-inch ice scraper on Amazon or AstroAI (two-pack).

Best Bang for the Buck

The Best Ice Scraper Option: Snow Joe 2-in-1 Snow Broom with Ice Scraper
Photo: amazon.com

Snow Joe’s two-in-one snow broomand ice scraper makes massive snowfalls less overwhelming. An 18-inch head uses a lightweight foam headinstead of bristles to remove snow from the car without scratches or other damage. The ice scraper, integrated into the bottom of the brush, features plastic teeth to break up thick ice.

Constructed of interlocking extension poles, this telescoping scraper extends 52 inches. That extra reach makes it a go-to tool to get ice and snow off large or high windows. All this fits into an easy-to-maneuver 1.4-pound tool. One thing users may miss in this lightweight device is an ergonomic handle.

When not in use, the pole breaks down into three pieces and fits into brackets built into the brush head for compact car storage.

Product Specs

  • Type: Snow broom/ice scraper
  • Length: 52 inches at its longest
  • Weight: 1.4 pounds

Pros

  • Extendable snow brushfor longer reach
  • Oversize foam headto remove snow without damage
  • Compact storage for the vehicle

Cons

  • No grip on the handle

Get the Snow Joe ice scraper at Amazon, The Home Depot, Tractor Supply Co., Best Buy, or Snow Joe.

Best with Brush

The Best Ice Scraper Option: Amazon Basics Snow Brush & Ice Scraper
Photo: amazon.com

All too often, winter storms start with sleet and ice that eventually turns to snow, so drivers have to brush off a layer of the white stuff before they can scrape away the ice. The AstroAI 3 in 1 Ice Scraper handles both jobs efficiently.

It comes with a soft foam grip and a telescoping pole that extends up to 47.2 inches, which is long enough to brush snow from vehicle hoods, trunks, and roofs. The brush features layered bristles and a pivoting head that adjusts at the push of a button to any angle—up to 180 degrees—for brushing away snow from hard-to-reach spots. As a bonus, the AstroAI also comes with a silicone squeegee that quickly clears melted ice from windows without leaving streaks.

Product Specs

  • Type: Snow broom/ice scraper
  • Length: 36.6 to 47.2 inches
  • Weight: 1.5 pounds

Pros

  • Expands up to 47.2 inches to reach high spots
  • Soft foam grip for comfort
  • Features snow brush and squeegee
  • Head pivots to reach angles

Cons

  • Requires assembly each time before use

Get the AstroAI 3-in-1 ice scraper on Amazon or AstroAI.

Best with Mitt

The Best Ice Scraper Option: BIRDROCK HOME Ice Scraper Mitt for Car Windshield
Photo: amazon.com

No gloves? No problem. BirdRock Home’s scraper features a warm and cozy mitt to keep fingers from turning into icicles when removing ice from car windows. Lined with soft faux fur and wrapped in waterproof material, the mitt detaches from the scraper for cleaning. The scraper handle fits snugly inside the mitt so users can grip it with a warm, dry hand.

Made from high-quality plastic, the handheld windshield ice scraper won’t bend or snap, even on thicker ice. Non-scratch jaws help break through ice, and then a flat blade gets underneath the ice to clear it away. A cleverly curved design redirects the ice and snow away from the user so hands stay warm and dry.

Product Specs

  • Type: Ice-scraper mitt
  • Length: 15 inches with glove, 9.5 inches without glove
  • Weight: 8 ounces

Pros

  • Faux-fur interior
  • Durable, high-quality plastic
  • Ice scraper is detachable
  • Curved design deflects ice or snowflakes

Cons

  • No brush for snow removal
  • Short reach

Get the BirdRock Home ice scraper mitt at Amazon, The Home Depot, or BirdRock Home (two-pack).

Best Multipurpose

The Best Ice Scraper Option: SubZero 51 Ice Crusher Snowbroom and Squeegee
Photo: amazon.com

Where most ice scrapers only make themselves useful for a few months out of the year, SubZero’s lightweight snow broomand squeegee offers year-round uses, earning it a permanent place in the car.

Made from a solid metal shaft and heavy-duty plastic, the small-but-mighty scraper includes ice chippers for windows covered in thick ice. A snow brush with a pivoting head employs both long, soft bristles and short, rigid ones to remove both powder snow and heavy, wet snow effectively. Users can adjust the brush headto their desired position. Opposite the brush, a rubber ice-scraper squeegee clears windows of snow and debris and helps keep the windshield clean year-round. A telescoping handle extends to a whopping 51 inches to help clear away every last snowflake.

Product Specs

  • Type: Ice crusher/broom/squeegee
  • Length: 51 inches
  • Weight: 1.1 pounds

Pros

  • Less clutter as a 3-in-1 tool
  • Long-lasting materials
  • Pivoting head for customized positioning
  • 2 foam grips for comfort

Cons

  • The swivel can be difficult to adjust

Get the SubZero 51-inch ice scraper on Amazon.

Best for Glove Compartment

The Best Ice Scraper Option: Hopkins Subzero Ice Crusher Ice Scraper
Photo: amazon.com

This basic ice scraper by SubZero fits in a glove box with room to spare for insurance papers, an owner’s manual, snacks, and other car accessories. This 11-inch scraper works hard to clear ice from the windshield. Even with a full-size scraper in the car, it may be worth keeping this small backup in the glove compartment.

At 4.5 inches wide, the thick plastic blade stacks up against blades on larger scrapers. The compact design includes ice-chipper teeth on the opposite end to help smash through tough ice on colder days.

A small oval handle with a soft foam gripmakes it comfortable to hold and maneuver. As this is a handheld scraper, users swap longer reach for convenient storage, which may be preferred for smaller vehicles.

Product Specs

  • Type: Ice crusher/scraper
  • Length: 11 inches
  • Weight: 4 ounces

Pros

  • Small enough to store for emergencies
  • 4.5-inch-wide blade
  • Soft grip for comfort and control
  • Serrated ice chipper cuts through ice

Cons

  • Small handle keeps hands near ice and snow when scraping

Get the SubZero Ice Crusher ice scraper on Amazon or at O’Reilly Auto Parts.

Best for Trucks and SUVs

The Best Ice Scraper Option: BIRDROCK HOME Snow MOOver 55 Snow Brush Ice Scraper
Photo: amazon.com

Large trucks and SUVs require an ice scraper with incredible reach. BirdRock Home’s lightweight ice scraper and snow brush helps remove the signs of winter from tall vehicles with its telescoping 55-inch reach.

A thick plastic ice scraper with built-in jaws, this product by BirdRock Home quickly breaks up large chunks of ice while the soft foam griphandle keeps hands comfortable and securely in place.

Trading bristles for foam, the sturdy, oversize brush removes a lot of snow with each pass, but it won’t damage the tops of vehicles. Even better, the freeze-resistant rotating brush head allows users to customize the angle to make clearing the snow easier. Need a hand? Detach the scraper from the brush to split the work between two people.

This handy tool comes apart for storage but still takes a little more space in the car than the average scraper.

Product Specs

  • Type: Snow brush/ice scraper
  • Length: 55 inches
  • Weight: 1.98 pounds

Pros

  • Freeze-resistant foam brush head
  • Thick plastic jaws for scraping tough ice
  • Removable ice scraper
  • Pivoting head for greater control

Cons

  • Foam brush head takes up a lot of room

Get the BirdRock Home Snow MOOver ice scraper at Amazon, The Home Depot, or BirdRock Home.

Best for Driveways

The Best Ice Scraper Option: Bully Tools Heavy Duty Sidewalk and Ice Scraper
Photo: amazon.com

As the name suggests, Bully Tools’ snow shovels stand up to snow and ice. Its sidewalk and ice scraper ranks as a go-to tool for removing stubborn ice chunks off any property and eliminates safety hazards and liabilities. The tool makes ice removal fast so users can get back inside where it’s warm.

A wide 11-gauge steel handle ensures that the ice scraper holds up to use. Made in one solid piece, it resists bending or breaking. Routine sharpening of the carbon-steel blade extends its life and makes it more effective at chipping away ice. At over 6 pounds, the weight of the scraper helps break up ice, but it will fatigue the user after extended periods of use.

Product Specs

  • Type: Sidewalk/driveway ice scraper
  • Length: 46 inches (D-grip); 58 inches (long handle)
  • Weight: 4 to 5 pounds, depending on grip chosen

Pros

  • Heavy-duty 11-gauge steel handle
  • Blade can be resharpened
  • Wide handle with comfortable grip
  • Made in America

Cons

  • Starts to feel heavy when clearing a lot of ice at once

Get the Bully Tools ice scraper at Amazon, The Home Depot, Lowe’s, or Bully Tools.

What to Consider When Choosing the Best Ice Scraper

The best ice scraper depends on a user’s specific needs and the climate where they live. Areas with harsher winter weather require a more robust solution for clearing ice, while in warmer climates, people may get away with using a more basic ice scraper. Below we outline the size, design, and features to look for in the best ice scraper.

Size and Length

Those who drive a compact car with a windshield that’s easy to reach from both sides may find that a basic ice scraper—one that’s up to 12 inches in length—best fits their needs. These handy winter tools are easy to store. Most drivers usually stow a small ice scraper away in a glove compartment or a tote so they always have it around when needed. Larger vehicles, such as SUVs or pickup trucks, may call for a longer scraper to reach the windshield.

For the longest reach, shoppers will want to consider a telescoping ice scraper with an adjustable handle that extends anywhere from 30 to 60 inches to manage those hard-to-reach spots.

Blade Design

An ice scraper should feel solidly constructed when it’s held. Those thin plastic scrapers given out by banks and hardware stores during the holidays might help remove a light coating of frost from a windshield, but they won’t make a dent in heavy ice buildup. Serious ice buildup needs serious winter tools to remove it. Shoppers should look for blades made of hefty acrylic or molded plastic (up to 0.375-inch thick).

Most scrapers come with a dual-use blade that’s smooth on one side to remove frost and light ice accumulation and toothed on the other (just flip it over) for serious scraping to cut through thick ice. Anyone who lives in an area that regularly receives ice storms will want to choose a scraper with large, pronounced teeth to banish heavy ice buildup effectively.

Ease of Use

To scrape away ice that seems permanently bonded to a car’s windshield, shoppers will want to look for a handle that’s every bit as robust as the blade. Quality ice scrapers often have ergonomic handles designed for an easy grip when applying firm pressure. Many of today’s top models also offer foam padding for a tight, comfortable grip.

The weight of an ice scraper should also figure into the selection process. A heavy ice scraper packs more heft, making it tougher to push the ice off a windshield or driveway. In general, the larger the ice scraper, the heavier it will be.

Handheld scrapers usually range between 2 and 8 ounces, while nonextending windshield ice scrapers are typically between 12 ounces and 2 pounds; full-size ice scrapers are somewhere between 3 and 6 pounds. Of course, the weight of an ice scraper depends on its construction and the construction materials.

Additional Features

Clever features can make ice scraping a lot more pleasant. Here are some of our favorites:

  • Snow brushes sweep off the snow before scraping the windshield. The best snow brushes for cars have firm bristles (soft bristles bend easily, leaving snow behind) or a thick foam head for efficient snow removal.
  • Mitts help protect hands while scraping ice. On some models, the scraper handle comes encased in a lined, waterproof mitten so users can scrape heartily without freezing their fingers or scraping their knuckles on snow and ice shards.
  • Hammers or crushers smash through stubborn ice and make it easier to remove. Ice scrapers with this feature usually have a thicker end that resembles a hammer or serrated teeth for crushing ice.
  • Extendable shafts reach farther to clear ice and snow more efficiently. The telescoping feature also makes for easier storage inside the vehicle.

FAQs

Despite all the details offered in this guide, many shoppers might still have a few lingering questions about how to choose the best ice scraper for their cars or driveways. Some aren’t sure what type of tool works as an ice scraper, while others worry about an ice scraper or snow brush damaging their vehicles, scratching the paint or glass. Here are answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about ice scrapers.

Q. What can be used as an ice scraper?

Items made from soft plastic, like a card, spatula, or plastic dustpan, can stand in for an ice scraper. These items may crack, though, if the ice is too thick.

Q. Is it safe to scrape ice off windshields?

Scraping ice off windshields is safe if done slowly. There aren’t any real shortcuts or tricks.

Q. Does a snow brush scratch a car?

Yes, snow brushes can leave tiny scratches on a vehicle’s paint. If the vehicle is dirty, the brush may push and grind that dirt into the paint.

Q. Can you sharpen an ice scraper?

Yes, this is done using 100-, 150-, or 240-grit sandpaper. It’s not worth sharpening an ice scraper unless the user fully knows what they’re doing.

Why Trust Bob Vila

Bob Vila has been America’s Handyman since 1979. As the host of beloved and groundbreaking TV series including “This Old House” and “Bob Vila’s Home Again,” he popularized and became synonymous with “do-it-yourself” home improvement.

Over the course of his decades-long career, Bob Vila has helped millions of people build, renovate, repair, and live better each day—a tradition that continues today with expert yet accessible home advice. The Bob Vila team distills need-to-know information into project tutorials, maintenance guides, tool 101s, and more. These home and garden experts then thoroughly research, vet, and recommend products that support homeowners, renters, DIYers, and professionals in their to-do lists.