The Best Toilet Seats for Bathroom Upgrades

A seat in one of the most peaceful rooms of the house should maximize comfort and functionality while enhancing aesthetics.

BobVila.com and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.

Best Toilet Seat

Photo: istockphoto.com

An updated bathroom adds value to your home while matching your design preferences and family’s needs. Toilets can play a significant role in enhancing the aesthetics of your bath and vanity areas.

A toilet seat that appears flimsy or cracked is not only an eyesore but is an indicator of a poor-quality product that can cause an unhygienic bathroom.

The best toilet seats are made with superior products that can support significant weight, are easy to clean, and bring comfort to a place of privacy. The selections below are the best in their respective categories.

  1. BEST OVERALL: Kohler K4639-58 Cachet Quiet-Close Toilet Seat
  2. BEST VALUE: Bemis 70000 Toilet Seat
  3. UPGRADE PICK: BioBidet Supreme BB-1000 Elongated Toilet Seat
  4. ALSO CONSIDER: Mayfair 841EC 047 Enameled Wood Toilet Seat
Best Toilet Seat

Photo: istockphoto.com

What to Look for When Buying the Best Toilet Seat

Any purchase should dictate a certain level of prior research and knowledge about the product. Whether it is a simple question about available colors or a detailed inquiry about the specific weight restrictions on an item, this information is essential. Before buying, consider these critical factors that can impact your decision.

Shape

The toilet bowl’s design indicates the shape of the toilet seat required. Toilet bowls generally come in two standard shapes: Elongated and round.

To find out which toilet seat you need, measure the length of the bowl. Find the center between the seat bolts and measure to the outside edge of the front of the bowl. An elongated bowl will measure between 18 inches to 18.5 inches, while a round bowl will measure about 16.5 inches. If you are also purchasing a new toilet, there are a few factors to consider between elongated and round options:

  • Elongated toilets tend to be more comfortable for adults, easier to get off for those with mobility issues, but they take up more room and are a bit restricting in a small bathroom.
  • Round toilets are better for smaller people and could be an ideal solution for a child’s bathroom. They are less powerful on average than elongated models, but also have a lower price tag.

Material

When selecting a toilet seat, you can choose the material for the bolts, hinges, and seat itself. The hinge material selection is designed for durability—with stainless steel and zinc-plated options being on the high end and plastic on the low end. If the toilet seat is in the main bathroom of the home, consider going with high-end material.

Bolts come in metal or plastic. Metal bolts offer strength and stability, with little flex for twisting seats. However, they are more susceptible to the humidity and moisture of a bathroom environment. Plastic bolts don’t rust, so they are easier to remove for cleaning, but they lack the strength of metal bolts. If residents of the home are larger, consider the metal bolts instead.

The seat itself can come in plastic or wood. Plastic options naturally resist moisture and are easy to clean. They are also more durable over time because wooden seats absorb moisture and begin to crack and warp. Wooden seats are generally better for secondary bathrooms, as their aesthetic appeal can outweigh their long-term functionality issues.

Color

The toilet seat’s color helps a toilet blend into the background of a designer bathroom; or highlight a neutral scheme with a burst of brightness. Most often, a toilet seat color comes down to what a specific product offers and what matches the current bathroom design.

Ultimately, color is an individual preference, but popular toilet seat brands most often offer neutral colors. So, if a wide selection in a specific brand is important, opt for a range of neutral tones, and you will be more likely to find one that you love.

Installation 

Installing and tightening the toilet seat is usually an easy project you can complete in a few moments by removing the old bolts and seat and installing the newer versions.

The type of bolts you get with the new toilet seat won’t impact the installation, but the bolts’ condition on the existing toilet seat might. Rusted metal bolts can quickly turn this simple job into something more complicated. A liquid lubricating oil can loosen up the bolts, or in extreme cases, a hacksaw can cut through them. Some toilet seat manufacturers offer hardware that is supposedly easier to install than a nut and bolt, with specialty wingnuts that lock into place so that the top of the bolt only needs to be screwed in using a screwdriver. It’s a nice feature if you have never worked with a wrench before and wouldn’t be comfortable beyond a screwdriver.

Other options to consider for installation are quick-release toilet seats that detach from the bolts for easy cleaning. Being able to remove the entire seat without wrestling with bolts means you can sanitize it more frequently, increasing the cleanliness of the bathroom.

Additional Features

Toilet seats have come a long way from simple pieces of wood with holes in them. Among the features discussed above, several additional elements can quickly enhance a toilet seat’s functionality. Quiet-closing toilet seats shut with controlled hinges that gently bring the seat down to rest on the bowl. Bumpers sit on the bottom of the toilet seat, protecting the porcelain, but also gripping the bowl to prevent the toilet seat from shifting.

High-end models have heated seats, massage streams, and built-in bidet systems, bringing a luxury experience to your home. Advanced nozzle placement, drying features, and water temperature control are just a few of the available features for those willing to spend the money.

Our Top Picks

The selections below have been chosen based on the considerations outlined above, the toilet seat efficacy, and the overall reputation of the toilet seat and manufacturer.

Best Toilet Seat KOHLER

Photo: amazon.com

BEST OVERALL: Kohler K-4639-58 Cachet Quiet-Close Toilet Seat

Designed for optimization, the Kohler Quiet-Close Toilet Seat is available in elongated and rounded versions. Both styles also include 10 different color choices, allowing you to customize your toilet seat to your bathroom design. Quiet-close functionality means you no longer need to worry about slamming the lid on the bowl or your hand, and the solid plastic cover resists staining, fading, chipping, and peeling for a great look over time.

With Kohler’s quick-attach hardware, the installation of this seat couldn’t be easier. After installation, quick-release hinges allow the seat to easily be removed from the bolts for regular cleaning, making your bathroom smell and look better. Comfort, selection, and functionality combine to make this the best overall toilet seat.

Best Toilet Seat BEMIS

Photo: amazon.com

BEST VALUE: Bemis 70 000 Toilet Seat

Toilet seats don’t have to be expensive, especially if they are going into a guest bathroom or seasonal home. The Bemis 70 000 Toilet Seat doesn’t hurt the wallet and comes in both elongated and round styles. A top installation system means you won’t have to get down on your hands and knees to complete this easy installation with locking wing nuts. Four bumpers on the bottom of the seat hold it in place during use and prevent unwanted shifting that could damage the hinges. The plastic material is easy to clean and resists any water damage. There isn’t a toilet seat better for the price.

Best Toilet Seat BioBidet

Photo: amazon.com

UPGRADE PICK: BioBidet Supreme BB-1000 Elongated Toilet Seat

The BioBidet Supreme Toilet Seat is never going to be a guest room feature, with a price tag well above the average toilet seat. However, for luxury consumers, or those looking to spoil themselves, the 3-in-1 adjustable nozzle for advanced aim and pressure will introduce you to a whole new experience.

The heated seat solves the issue of sitting down on cold plastic in the middle of the night and comes in elongated or round options. Water temperature control on the sprayer keeps you warm even during cleaning, and a built-in dryer removes the need for excess toilet paper. However, the installation will be more complicated than the usual two bolts, due to the inclusion of a water tank.

Best Toilet Seat MAYFAIR

Photo: amazon.com

ALSO CONSIDER: Mayfair 841EC 047 Enameled Wood Toilet Seat

Wooden toilet seats add a certain aesthetic appeal to a bathroom that plastic options can’t match. With nine different color choices, the enameled wood of this toilet seat looks stunning but should be cleaned using only mild soap and water. The Mayfair Enameled Wood Toilet Seat uses a fastening system that resists movement and twisting at the hinges. The bolts are wrapped in a hard plastic that prevents slipping in the porcelain holes. Additionally, the bolts are designed to stop additional torque from the wrench after the nut has reached optimal tightness. You can remove the toilet seat from the bolts with a quick-release system that makes cleaning easy, for a neat and hygienic bathroom.

FAQs About Your New Toilet Seat

There is nothing worse than confidently purchasing a product, getting it home, and realizing that you still have a ton of questions about whether it is right for you. Skip the regret and take a look at the answers to some common questions about the best toilet seats below.

Q. What is the maximum weight that a standard toilet seat can hold?

The weight limit of the standard toilet seat ranges by manufacturer, but the average maximum weight is between 300 pounds and 500 pounds.

Q. How can I find the right size for my toilet?

To find the right size toilet seat for your toilet, measure the length of the toilet seat, the width of the toilet seat, and the distance between the bolts.

Q. How do you replace the toilet seat?

You can replace the toilet seat by removing the old bolts from the existing seat with a screwdriver and a socket wrench, then installing the new one with a set of new bolts (metal or plastic usually). Pay attention to the amount that you tighten the bolts. If you tighten them too much, the seat (or porcelain of the toilet) can crack. If they are too loose, the seat will move around when in use, causing the hinges to bend and break.

Q. What size are toilet seat bolts?

The average bolt size is ⅜” x 2 ½”, though other sizes are available for industrial toilets, heavy-duty toilet seats, or specialty toilets.