Latest Discussions : Tools & Workshop


10:57AM | 04/11/03
Member Since: 04/06/03
19 lifetime posts
I have an 8 x 12 kitchen and I am considering putting down one of two types of floors: Pergo or ceramic tile.

Here are the two problem installs I am running into that I need your adivce with.

1. Pergo - installer said that since we do not have any ventilation underneath the kitchen floor that they cannot gurantee that the Pergo will stay in place. They suggested that they open up a window underneath the room in order to circulate air and then they would suggest laying Pergo down.

2. Ceramic - it was suggested that the current peel and press tile be lifted, that the wood floor underneath be picked up so that they can lay down the cement then lay down the ceramic tile. I was told that the cement that they put down first is approximately 3/4 inch thick and then the ceramic tile can be put in place. I currently have a marble saddle separating the kitchen and dining room. By doing it the above way I would need to have the saddle custom in order to be above the ceramic tile. (most expensive method)

Another method was to lay the ceramic tile down over the current tile floor (cheapest method)

A third and final method suggested was to lift the peel and press and just lay the ceramic tile on top of the wooden floor. (mid-priced method)

The installers were provided by Home Depot - where I bought the tile.

Your suggestions and comments on this would be appreciated.




05:37PM | 04/12/03
Member Since: 04/10/03
116 lifetime posts
if you lay the tile over the peel and stick, then the cement will only be as strong as the glue on the peel and stick. i myself would pull up the peel and stick and go for it.


06:34PM | 04/17/03
Member Since: 11/14/00
333 lifetime posts
That is not necessarily true. You would need to install a cementboard (not cement!)subfloor as the underlayment for the ceramic tile, anyway. You can secure cementboard through the peel-and-stick tiles to the wooden subfloor underneath with screws. Cementboard comes in large sheets a bit smaller than drywall does.

Nonetheless, you should remove the peel-and-stick flooring, anyway, and THEN install the cementboard. I don't know what you mean by "pick up" the wood floor, but if you mean "remove," that is not only not necessary, it might be wrong.

Pull up the peel and stick and install cementboard and then the tile on top of the wood floor.

Pergo is not as nice a tile in my opinion.


01:15AM | 04/18/03
Member Since: 04/06/03
19 lifetime posts
Thaks for everyone's comments, I appreciate them. My wife and I decided to go the ceramic tile route. We will lift the peel and press tile ourselves. The installer will lay down the backing that was mentioned then lay the ceramic tile over that. We will also be using a beautiful marble saddle to separate the two rooms.

Thanks again.

Post a reply as Anonymous

Photo must be in JPG, GIF or PNG format and less than 5MB.

Reply choose button


Post new button or Login button