The Best Comforters for Your Bed

With the right comforter, bedtime feels like a dream. One of these cozy comforters can wrap you up and take you to dreamland.

BobVila.com and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.

The Best Comforter Option

Photo: amazon.com

Since you spend a third of your life sleeping, your bed is one of the most important parts of your home. It’s more than just a place to rest at the end of the day—it should be a comfortable haven that helps you get away from the stresses of daily life. To get the best sleep possible, the best comforter is key.

When you climb under the right comforter, you may feel as if you’re nestled into a cloud. The best comforters are fluffy and warm while also staying breathable. The right comforter for you varies according to your lifestyle and needs. Some love the weight of a heavy blanket on cold nights, while others prefer a lightweight covering. Budget is also an important consideration, and industry pricing can vary widely. The good news is that you don’t need to splurge to get a high-quality product that will last for years.

  1. BEST OVERALL: Luxurious Siberian Goose Down Comforter
  2. RUNNER-UP: drtoor Luxurious Down Comforter, All Seasons Duvet
  3. BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK: Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert
  4. FOR HOT SLEEPERS: SLEEP ZONE All Season Comforter Down Alternative 
  5. BEST DOWN: Luxurious All-Season Goose Down Comforter Duvet
  6. BEST DOWN ALTERNATIVE: Buffy Cloud Comforter
  7. BEST LIGHTWEIGHT: WhatsBedding Down Alternative Quilted Comforter
The Best Comforter Option

Photo: depositphotos.com

What to Consider When Choosing the Best Comforter

Before you begin to shop for a comforter, weigh some key considerations. While one of the most obvious choices is between a down or a down-alternative fill material, that’s just one of several options. Read on to find out what else to keep in mind when shopping for the best comforter for your bed.

Fill Material

The gold standard for bedding fill material is down. Down filling consists of the fluffy underlayer that waterfowl have beneath their exterior feathers. It not only has excellent insulating properties, but it’s remarkably lightweight. While goose down is generally considered the ideal filling material, it’s actually not noticeably superior to duck down, which can be slightly more affordable.

When shopping for a down comforter, be sure to look for products that are labeled “100% down.” Some duvets, although they’re marketed as having a down filling, actually contain a high percentage of other feathers. While down and feathers can come from the same species, the latter doesn’t offer the same insulation.

For affordable and allergen-free bedding, consider down-alternative filling. Unlike the real deal, this option won’t irritate sleepers with allergies or asthma. Today’s market contains a plethora of down-alternative options made with cotton, polyester, siliconized fibers, and more. These may not breathe as well as true down comforters, but they’re more likely to be washable and within budget.

Weight 

Fill weight refers to the amount of filling in the comforter. The ideal fill weight depends on your personal preference—some sleepers like a light, airy duvet, while others prefer the feeling of a heavier covering.

Fill power, on the other hand, is one key indicator of a comforter’s warmth. It’s calculated by measuring the volume in cubic inches per an ounce of down. A comforter with a high fill power provides extra insulation without adding more weight. If you live in an area with cold winter nights, look for a comforter with a fill power of at least 600. Those who live in warmer climates or who often get overheated at night should choose a fill power under 500. In down-alternative comforters, a measurement of grams per square meter (GSM) offers a similar gauge of weight.

Thread Count 

Thread count typically helps you sort out the best sheets, but it’s also an important factor when choosing a comforter. A higher thread count translates to a more tightly woven fabric. Though your comforter may not need to be quite as soft as the rest of your bedding, especially if you use a duvet cover and/or top sheet, high thread count is still an indicator of a superior product.

More important than softness is whether the shell is “downproof.” A higher thread count makes it less likely that your filling gradually leaks out over time and causes a dusty, billowy mess.

In a comforter, you should be looking for a thread count of 300 or higher. Though some comforters boast thread counts of more than 1,000, you don’t need to go that high to have a perfectly functional and cozy product.

Stitch Design

Without additional stitching in the comforter’s interior, the comforter’s filling may shift around and end up creating an uneven loft throughout. Several construction styles prevent this from happening, but baffle boxing is generally considered to work best.

Baffle boxing involves the creation of stitched pockets in the shape of squares or rectangles with an extra strip of fabric that encourages higher loft. Each square contains an equal amount of filling, so you don’t have to worry about your comforter staying fluffy in one corner but flat in another.

Sewn-through comforters are another popular (and less expensive) alternative. Sewn-through comforters use a technique similar to baffle boxing, but they allow for more heat loss, making this style preferable for lightweight duvets.

Machine Washability 

While some comforters don’t require a duvet cover, using one helps extend the life of your product. Even so, you should wash your comforter about once every six months to every year, depending on the fill material.

Many down comforters are dry-clean only, but one of the advantages of down alternatives is that you can often clean them at home in a large-capacity washing machine. To avoid the potential for damage, be sure to look for cleaning instructions that clearly state the product can be cleaned in a machine.

Climate and Season

There’s no one right comforter for every sleeper. The perfect choice for you depends on your location and how warm you like to be while you’re sleeping. Those who live in warmer climates—or who tend to overheat at night—don’t typically need comforters with a high fill power.

Some people prefer to keep one comforter for summer but use another one during the cooler months. If you live in a temperate climate, a mid-range fill power should be comfortable year-round. Balancing fill power with fill weight is key in guaranteeing that your comforter suits your lifestyle and climate.

Our Top Picks

The following recommendations take into account all the considerations mentioned, including fill power, weight, thread count, construction, and, most importantly, quality. This list features a variety of choices of top-notch comforters to help you find the right one for you according to your sleep preferences, climate, and budget.

Best Overall

The Best Comforter Option: Luxurious Siberian Goose Down Comforter
Photo: amazon.com

With a fill power of 750 and fill weight of 48 ounces, Luxurious Siberian Goose Down Comforter provides plenty of warmth while still remaining relatively lightweight. Its baffle box construction and 1,200-thread count, 100 percent Egyptian cotton mean the 100 percent Siberian goose down filling stays in place and provides an even layer of comfort and warmth.

The down in this comforter has been certified by the Responsible Down Standard (RDS), which means that animal welfare practices were followed to ensure that no geese were subjected to unduly harmful treatment during the manufacturing process. The fabrics also meet OEKO-Tex standards, guaranteeing that no chemicals are present that could cause adverse effects.

Runner-Up

The Best Comforter Option: drtoor Luxurious Down Comforter, All Seasons Duvet Insert
Photo: amazon.com

The drtoor Luxurious Down Comforter is made with 100 percent goose down that meets RDS certification standards. Additionally, it meets Down Pass standards, which ensures ethical production was practiced during its manufacture.

Its fill power of 750 along with a 42-ounce fill weight means that it’s heavy enough to use in cold months but still provide lightweight coverage. Plus, with a shell composed of 1,200-thread count, 100 percent cotton material, that down won’t leak out over time. Instead, the tight weave keeps it locked in, and a baffle box construction ensures even distribution of the fill. The eight loop tabs make it easy to attach to your duvet cover, so the insert won’t move around while you sleep.

Best Bang for the Buck

The Best Comforter Option: Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert
Photo: amazon.com

This affordable choice, which is fluffy and cloud-like, features a soft outer shell. Since the down-alternative consists of siliconized fiberfill, its loft is measured in GSM rather than fill power. With a GSM of 350, the Utopia Bedding Comforter is a versatile choice for year-round use.

This is an excellent choice for guest rooms or other spaces where you may not want to make a significant investment, but it also holds its own alongside pricier comforters. The Utopia comforter comes in a variety of colors, so in a pinch, it can work as an all-in-one option without a cover. Then, when it’s time to clean, this machine washable comforter won’t require trips to the dry cleaner; simply toss into a large washer.

For Hot Sleepers

The Best Comforter Option: SLEEP ZONE All Season Comforter Down Alternative
Photo: amazon.com

If you often get overheated even on cool nights, a traditional comforter may not suit your needs. The moisture-wicking properties of the Nanotex fabric used in this SLEEP ZONE All-Season Down Alternative comforter ensure that the material dries quickly to keep you comfortable through the night. The interior is made up of siliconized microfiber, which is a down alternative that will help keep you cool. Moreover, its light weight (120 GSM) helps the cause. Unlike the checkerboard stitching design on most comforters, this one utilizes a U-shaped pattern intended to contour to your body as you sleep.

While this comforter is meant to be used with a cover, hot sleepers who wish to launder their comforters more often are in luck! It’s machine washable.

Best Down

The Best Comforter Option: Luxurious All-Season Goose Down Comforter Duvet Insert
Photo: amazon.com

For those living in cold climates or who like to be as cozy as possible when sleeping, this down comforter is a great choice. The Luxurious All-Season Comforter is filled with 100 percent goose down with no feather filler. It has a fill power of 750 and a fill weight of 55 ounces, which means it will keep you warm and also provide a satisfying weight. Its 1,200-thread count gives the material an extra-soft feeling, and it will help it retain its down over the years. The baffle box construction ensures even down distribution.

This comforter meets RDS, OEKO-Tex, and BSCI standards. So not only is it made cruelty-free with no harmful chemicals, it also meets optimal workplace conditions criteria established by the Business Social Compliance Initiative.

Best Down Alternative

The Best Comforter Option: Buffy Cloud Comforter
Photo: amazon.com

Shoppers who are interested in prioritizing environmentally friendly options for the home may especially appreciate the Buffy Cloud Comforter. Inside, the fill is 100 percent recycled fiber; outside, the shell is made from eucalyptus fabric, which requires less water to produce than cotton. It’s also breathable and lightweight, too, making this a comforter that works well year-round.

Not only is this choice “green,” but it’s also ideal for allergy sufferers thanks to a shell that’s resistant to mites, dust, and mold. Even though it’s a down-alternative comforter, Buffy recommends dry cleaning instead of laundering at home.

Best Lightweight

The Best Comforter Option: WhatsBedding Down Alternative Quilted Comforter
Photo: amazon.com

If you’re looking for a lightweight comforter to use in the warmer months, consider this versatile down alternative. Affordable, hypoallergenic, and even machine washable, it can be used either as a comforter or duvet insert. The filling is made of microfiber with a fill rate of 160 GSM, one of the lowest options on the market. While some sleepers prefer a high loft in their comforters, this model is thinner and well-suited for those seeking a lighter, more low-profile option.

FAQ About Your New Comforter 

With all the choices available, finding the best comforter can be a bit overwhelming, so you might still have some questions. Here are the answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about comforters.

Q. What makes a good comforter?

The best comforter has a fill power and fill weight suitable for your lifestyle, comfort preference, and climate. In addition, a good comforter is constructed with durability in mind.

Q. How often do you wash a comforter?

Down comforters should be washed annually, while down-alternative comforters should be washed every six months. Heed the manufacturer’s instructions for care, whether that involves a trip to the dry cleaners or a cycle in the washing machine.

Q. What’s a comforter shell?

The comforter shell is the exterior fabric that contains the filling. It can be either plain or patterned.

Q. Do I need a duvet cover?

Ideally, to extend its life span, you should always use a duvet cover with your comforter, whether it’s designed to be used alone or not.

Q. What’s the difference between a comforter and a duvet?

Technically, a comforter is a blanket that doesn’t necessarily need a cover, while a duvet is an insert that’s paired with a duvet cover. In the United States, however, the two terms are often used interchangeably.