The Best Potting Soil for Your Container Plants

High-quality potting mix makes all the difference in plant performance. Choose the best potting soil for containers and watch your plants thrive.

BobVila.com and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.

The Best Potting Soil Option

Photo: depositphotos.com

Unlike soil amendments that mix into natural soil for gardening, potting soil is an all-in-one mixture for container plantings that contains everything potted plants need to thrive. It’s an essential ingredient for indoor and outdoor container gardening with two major roles: to store and release water and nutrients that plants use; and to provide a stable base for plants to structurally anchor themselves. As an anchoring system, the soil must have a porous structure that allows the roots to penetrate deeply. As a moisture reservoir, it balances water-holding capacity and drainage, so the roots remain damp but not soggy.

Potting soil (also called “potting mix”) ingredients are similar among all types and brands, but not all potting soils are the same. Companies formulate specific ingredient proportions for different growing conditions and plant types. Additives like fertilizer make big differences in overall performance. All this variety among products can make shopping for quality potting soil a bit of a challenge. This guide can help: Ahead, find shopping criteria, tips to help growers choose the right-size bag, and reviews for some of the best potting soils for container gardening needs.

  1. BEST OVERALL: Black Gold 1310102 16-Quart All Purpose Potting Soil
  2. BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK: Proven Winners Premium All Purpose Potting Soil 
  3. BEST ORGANIC: Espoma AP16 16-Quart Organic Potting Mix
  4. SEED STARTING PICK: Miracle-Gro Seed Starting Potting Mix, 8 Quart
  5. BEST FOR INDOOR PLANTS: Miracle-Gro Indoor Potting Mix 72776430 6 Quart 
  6. BEST FOR ORCHIDS: Perfect Plants All Natural Orchid Potting Mix 4 qt
  7. CACTI & SUCCULENTS PICK: Hoffman 10404 Cactus and Succulent Soil Mix 4 qt
  8. BEST FOR RAISED BEDS: Miracle-Gro Raised Bed Soil, 1.5 cu. ft.
The Best Potting Soil Option

Photo: amazon.com

Types of Potting Soil

Plants in pots must have soil prepared specifically for container growing and for the environment in which the plants live. Outdoor containers are subject to hot sun, wind, and sudden rains that disrupt an ideal watering schedule, which means the soil used in outdoor containers should provide superior absorbency and aeration. Indoor containers are subject to moderate temperature, little or no direct sunlight, and water from the gardener’s hand only. For these containers, choose potting mixes that provide moisture consistency and resist degradation to avoid frequent repotting.

A few plant groups grow naturally in difficult environments; in fact, they actually suffer in “ideal” growing conditions. To thrive, plants like cacti and orchids need completely different growing media. Next, this guide dives into the different types of potting soils, which is best suited for specific requirements, and what to look for in each category.

All-Purpose

All-purpose potting soils are blended to provide a balance of moisture retention along with drainage of excess water for potted plants and container gardens. They are suitable to use indoors or outdoors. These soil blends are good for gardeners who place their potted plants in a variety of settings but prefer to buy only one product. While this type of soil can be used to grow a wide range of plants in various container types, all-purpose potting soils can dry out more quickly outdoors or retain too much water for certain houseplants.

All-purpose potting mixes often contain a conventional fertilizer that’s released as you water the plant. Many all-purpose soils are sterilized (heat-treated) to eliminate all living organisms, including weed seeds, insects, and plant diseases. Once opened, you should use the entire contents of a bag of sterile potting mix, or close and store it securely to maintain the benefits of its sterilization and moisture-retention qualities.

Organic Mix

Organic potting soil serves the same role as all-purpose soil, but it contains all organic ingredients. It’s especially popular for use in vegetable and herb gardening.

In organic potting soil, the plant food portion is broken down biologically by soil microbes, which often are added to the mix to feed the plants, instead of dissolving in water. Rather than sterilization, organic soil mixes are processed by composting. Composting reaches a high enough temperature to kill diseases, weed seeds, and insects, but it allows the beneficial fungi and bacteria to survive.

Seed Starting Mix

Seed starting mix is designed to sprout seeds for plants that gardeners transplant to a permanent home in the ground or a container. Gardeners typically use it in multicell trays in a highly controlled environment. Seed starting mix usually contains sterile, finely textured peat moss and perlite.

Sometimes, seed starting mixes contain no fertilizer because they’re intended for short-term use only—no longer than a month—during which time the young seedlings receive nourishment from the nutrients inside their seed coating. When the seedling must remain in the trays a bit longer, growers often add liquid fertilizer to help them thrive.

Outdoor Mix

Outdoor potting mix is heavier and coarser than indoor mix. In addition to retaining moisture in the hot sun, it must anchor plants to withstand strong winds. Outdoor potting mix has long fibers and a large particle size, which helps reduce the surface area and increases its water-holding capacity as it resists compaction. The open soil structure allows water to travel efficiently through the soil pores, where it’s either absorbed by the large particles or drains away freely. On hot, sunny, and dry days, the chunky soil particles gradually release their moisture, which helps keep the plants hydrated.

Plant-Specific Mix

While regular potting soil works well for most plants, a few plant types have adapted to very different growing conditions; as a result, they need potting soil with unique characteristics to help them thrive. Cacti and succulents prefer a mix that dries out quickly without compacting or shrinking away from the pot. Cactus mix, which often has a gravelly or sandy texture, usually contains a bit of organic matter to retain some moisture and nutrients. Certain orchids and bromeliads are epiphytic plants; in their natural habitat, they grow among the tree canopies in humid climates with no contact with soil. These plants perform well when potted in coarse bark or a mixture of bark, perlite, and peat moss.

The Best Potting Soil Option

Photo: depositphotos.com

What to Consider When Choosing the Best Potting Soil

Potting soil is a “soilless” mix, which means it contains no natural soil like that in your garden or on the forest floor. Instead, manufacturers blend organic and mineral ingredients, as well as other ingredients, such as wetting agents and fertilizer, to create the mix. As noted earlier, different soil blends perform well under different circumstances. When choosing the best potting soil, consider the type of plant and its fertilization needs as well as the potting soil’s ingredients and texture.

Plant Type

Many plants can thrive in most potting soils, so an all-purpose soil is a good choice for general use with houseplants and outdoor potted plants. However, if you’re growing edible herbs, veggies, and fruits, you may prefer an organic potting soil to help keep your entire growing environment system “all natural.”

Cacti and succulent plants need fast-draining soil with just a bit of organic matter, so you’ll want to find a specialty cactus mix for these plants. Many orchids and bromeliads dislike “wet feet,” but they still need a humid environment. Again, choose soil mixed specifically for orchids for the best growing conditions.

Ingredients

Peat moss and perlite are the most common ingredients in potting soils. Peat moss is the dead moss and other organic material that collects at the bottom of peat bogs, where it builds up in deep layers for hundreds of years before it’s harvested. It’s highly absorbent and naturally resistant to decay. Perlite is volcanic rock that’s mined, crushed, and super-heated, which makes it expand like popcorn to 20 times its original size. Perlite has an open structure that allows water and air to circulate freely, which helps promote drainage in the potting mix.

Bark is a byproduct of lumber milling that acts similarly to perlite. Composted forest products include sawdust, wood shavings, and decayed bark. These natural products add weight and density in addition to helping the soil retain moisture, all characteristics that are helpful when growing plants in outdoor containers and raised garden beds. Instead of peat moss, some manufacturers use coco coir, which is a material extracted from coconut shells and processed into a moisture-retentive fiber less acidic than peat moss.

Nutrients 

Vendors list potting soil nutrients on the product label as a ratio of percentages (based on total package weight) in the order of their nitrogen-phosphorus-potassium (N-P-K) content. Nutrients can be of either conventional chemical origin or organic.

Conventional nutrients are chemical formulations, such as ammonium nitrate and potassium sulfate, that dissolve with heat and moisture and are absorbed directly by the plant’s roots. These formulations are especially popular for houseplants or in conditions in which the grower doesn’t want to have fungal growth or other microorganisms present.

Organic nutrients come from composted manure, agricultural waste products, and other natural sources. Before the plant roots take up the materials, they are broken down by bacteria and fungi. These products are popular with gardeners who want to replicate the natural way that plants receive nourishment in the wild.

The nutrients supplied by potting soil last from a few weeks to a few months, but they eventually will run out. Over the long term, potted plants require additional fertilization. You can add granular or liquid fertilizer to the soil.

Aeration 

Soil aeration allows plant roots and water to penetrate through the mix, and it promotes healthy gas exchange between plant roots and the atmosphere. Varied particle sizes and decay-resistant ingredients help maintain good aeration in your potting soil. High-quality peat moss is composed of a mixture of large and small particles, and it’s naturally resistant to decay. As minerals, perlite and vermiculite don’t decay and help provide a healthy, open soil structure.

Moisture Control

Peat moss absorbs as much as 30 times its own weight in water, while coco coir can absorb nine times its weight. These attributes make them good base materials, but your plants need a balance to ensure that excess water drains away. Perlite helps ensure that plant roots get enough moisture, but not too much.

Some potting soils include a water-holding polymer that grabs even more excess moisture and slowly releases it after the surrounding soil has dried out. These ingredients help keep plants alive outdoors in intensely dry weather.

Fungal Growth

Mold grows on all kinds of organic material, including, if the conditions are right, pH-balanced sphagnum moss in potting soil. When you first purchase a bag of sterile potting soil, it doesn’t contain fungal spores, but it can begin to harbor them any time after you open the package. Organic potting soils often include beneficial fungi and bacteria that serve as intermediaries between plants and nutrients.

White fuzzy growth on the soil surface is harmless to plants; it’s a fungus feeding on the decaying ingredients in the potting soil. Simply scrape it off if it appears.

Fertilizer Starter Charge vs. Slow Release

Don’t rely solely on your potting soil to supply all of your plant’s nutrient requirements: They eventually will need fertilizer. Potting soil fertilizer comes either in a starter charge or slow-release formula. A starter charge is a light dose of plant food to help the plant become established, but after a few weeks, it diminishes. Slow-release fertilizer continues to feed for up to a few months, depending on the specific formulation. Read the label to know exactly when you’ll need to apply the next dose of plant food.

Our Top Picks

Potting soil is used for general container gardening and for very specific plant types. Be sure to choose a blend that meets your gardening needs. In this list, you’ll find some of the top choices for common uses and plant types.

Best Overall

The Best Potting Soil Option: Black Gold 1310102 16-Quart All Purpose Potting Soil
Photo: amazon.com

Black Gold 1310102 All Purpose Potting Soil in the 16-quart size is a nutrient-rich mix for growing most types of plants in containers. Its blend of 0.13 percent nitrogen, 0.05 percent phosphorus, and 0.10 percent potassium slow-release fertilizer supports lush foliage, deep rooting, and overall plant health. Black Gold potting mix contains Canadian sphagnum peat moss, plus worm castings, forest humus, and pumice.

This potting soil is suitable for both indoor and outdoor use. Its moderate drainage and water retention capabilities, along with its medium particle size, make it work well for houseplants, hanging baskets, patio containers, and container veggie and herb gardens. This is a nearly all-purpose choice for growers with different kinds of potted plants.

Best Bang for the Buck

The Best Potting Soil Option: Proven Winners Premium All Purpose Potting Soil
Photo: amazon.com

Proven Winners Premium All Purpose Potting Soil, in a 1.5-cubic-foot bag, comprises 50 to 60 percent Canadian sphagnum peat moss to help provide excellent water-holding capacity, processed softwood bark and perlite for aeration, and dolomitic lime to balance the pH. The company blends continuous release 15-7-15 (N-P-K) fertilizer into the mix to provide consistent feeding.

This is a medium-weight potting soil with excellent aeration and drainage capabilities. It’s especially formulated for growing vibrant flowering plants. As an all-purpose potting soil, it’s suitable for indoor or outdoor use, including growing houseplants and vegetables. It especially works well for patio containers and hanging baskets with annual flowers. You can purchase the 1.5-cubic-foot bag at a value price to fill several containers.

Best Organic

The Best Potting Soil Option: Espoma AP16 16-Quart Organic Potting Mix
Photo: amazon.com

Espoma AP16 16-Quart Organic Potting Mix is an all-purpose organic potting soil for use in indoor and outdoor container plantings. It’s made from 35 to 45 percent sphagnum peat moss, plus regionally sourced organic materials, such as aged forest products, humus, composted rice hulls, perlite, and limestone. Earthworm castings, alfalfa meal, kelp meal, and feather meal provide nutrients for a long, steady feed. Nine species of beneficial mycorrhizal fungi help promote root expansion and efficient feeding. Yucca extract, a natural wetting agent, promotes thorough moisture penetration.

This organic all-purpose potting mix is suitable for potted plants, indoors and out, and it’s especially suitable for growing container-grown vegetables and herbs. The organic mix also works well for container-grown habitats, such as balcony or patio butterfly and pollinator gardens.

Seed Starting Pick

The Best Potting Soil Option: Miracle-Gro Seed Starting Potting Mix, 8 Quart
Photo: amazon.com

Miracle-Gro Seed Starting Potting Mix is blended for fast seed germination and early, strong root growth. A mixture of 85 to 95 percent sphagnum peat moss and perlite provides a moist seed bed that provides good aeration for developing roots. Miracle-Gro plant food gives the mix a guaranteed fertilizer analysis of .03-.03-.03 N-P-K. The nutrients are derived from ammonium nitrate, ammonium phosphate, calcium phosphate, and potassium sulfate.

This lightweight specialty potting mix is designed for starting flower and vegetable seeds, as well as for propagating root, stem, and leaf cuttings. For best results, use a humidity dome over seed starting trays to keep the soil surface moist and speed up germination.

Best for Indoor Plants

The Best Potting Soil Option: Miracle-Gro Indoor Potting Mix 72776430 6 Quart
Photo: amazon.com

This two pack of 6-quart Miracle-Gro Indoor Potting Mix 72776430 is a premium potting soil that will significantly reduce the likelihood of pesky gnats indoors. It contains 60 to 70 percent sphagnum peat moss, coir, perlite, and fertilizer for an excellent balance of water retention, aeration, and drainage for growing most houseplants. Bark products and compost, which can harbor bothersome and potentially damaging fungus gnats, are left out of the mix. The .25-.13-.19 fertilizer analysis is derived from ammonium nitrate, ammonium phosphate, calcium phosphate, and potassium sulfate for a quick feed, plus polymer-coated ammonium nitrate, ammonium phosphate, calcium phosphate, and potassium sulfate to feed plants up to six months. This product comes as a two pack of 6-quart bags for a total of 12 quarts.

Best for Orchids

The Best Potting Soil Option: Perfect Plants All Natural Orchid Potting Mix 4 qt
Photo: amazon.com

Perfect Plants All Natural Orchid Potting Mix in a 4-quart bag is designed to allow ample space for orchid roots to climb and expand, while providing a moisture reservoir they can tap into. Charcoal, sponge rock (perlite), pine bark, and coconut chips provide a balanced environment by offering an open texture, while efficiently absorbing water and the nutrients that orchids need. This mix doesn’t compact or suffocate sensitive orchid roots.

This orchid mix can help grow phalaenopsis, oncidiums, cattleya, dendrobium, paphiopedilum, and other epiphytic orchids. For terrestrial orchids, mix equal parts of Perfect Plants All Natural Orchid Potting Mix and all-purpose potting soil.

Cacti & Succulents Pick

The Best Potting Soil Option: Hoffman 10404 Cactus and Succulent Soil Mix 4 qt
Photo: amazon.com

Hoffman 10404 Cactus and Succulent Soil Mix is designed to provide a healthy environment for cacti and succulent roots to penetrate deeply, while supporting drainage and healthy bloom development. It’s made from a blend of Canadian sphagnum peat moss, reed sedge peat, perlite, sand, and limestone. This organic mix can help succulent and cacti lovers grow both desert and jungle cacti as well as succulents.

This cactus and succulent potting soil doesn’t include a plant food component because of the wide variation in nutrient requirements in this plant category, so fertilizer is sold separately. Handling cacti can be challenging, but the soil label includes helpful repotting tips.

Best for Raised Beds

The Best Potting Soil Option: Miracle-Gro Raised Bed Soil, 1.5 cu. ft.
Photo: amazon.com

Miracle-Gro Raised Bed Soil in the 1.5-cubic-foot size is a 100 percent organic mix designed for growing vegetables, fruits, flowers, and herbs in raised beds. This blend of peat, processed forest products, compost, sphagnum peat moss, and coir provides an excellent balance of water-retention capacity, drainage, and aeration to support deep rooting and drought protection. Organic nutrients (.09-.08-.09 guaranteed NPK analysis, plus .02 percent calcium) are derived from poultry litter, alfalfa meal, bone meal, kelp meal, and earthworm castings.

This soil is premixed, and it’s ready to add directly to a raised bed without additional mixing. For growing edibles in raised beds or large containers, this nutrient-rich potting soil comes in a 1.5-cubic-foot bag.

How to Use Potting Soil

Potting soil is an all-in-one growing medium, so gardeners don’t need to add other types of soil or amendments to improve it. To repot a plant: Place a small amount of potting soil in the bottom of the new container, add the plant so the upper surface of its root ball is about ½ inch lower than the top of the pot, and firm in additional soil around the root ball until the soil is level with the root ball surface. Water thoroughly to eliminate air pockets, and it’s good to go.

Potting soil comes in different-size bags, typically in quarts or cubic feet. Common sizes are 4, 8, and 16 quarts, as well as 0.5, 1.0, and 1.5 cubic feet. For the sake of comparison, there are approximately 30 quarts in a cubic foot. Below is a list of standard pot sizes and the amount of potting soil it takes to fill each size. The measurements reflect the pot diameter inside the rim. Since pot volume changes with shape, consider this a guideline only.

  • 4-inch pots use about 0.5 quart of soil.
  • 6-inch pots use approximately 1 quart of soil.
  • 8-inch pots use about 3 quarts of soil.
  • 10-inch pots use around 5 quarts of soil.
  • 12-inch pots use approximately 12 quarts of soil.
  • 14-inch pots use about 18 quarts of soil.

FAQs About Your New Potting Soil

For best results, be sure to choose a potting soil suitable to your garden collection. Read on to learn more about choosing the best potting soil.

Q. Which is better: potting soil or potting mix?

Potting soil and potting mix are two names for the same type of product. Also watch for the terms “container soil” and “container mix.” All four of these products are “potting soil.” Avoid buying a product labeled “topsoil” or “gardening soil” for container plants without first checking the label. These products are intended for in-ground use.

Q. Which kind of soil is best for growing plants?

Plants need consistent moisture, good aeration, a steady nutrient supply, and a solid anchoring system. Potting soil is the best kind of soil for growing plants in containers because it provides all these characteristics.

Q. What’s the difference between indoor and outdoor potting soil?

Indoor potting soil dries out too quickly to be used outdoors, while outdoor potting soil retains too much moisture to be used indoors. If you want to buy only one product, all-purpose potting soil is designed to work well indoors or out.