Latest Discussions : Roofing & Siding

tjndnd

01:02PM | 05/09/14
Member Since: 05/09/14
1 lifetime posts
Hi,

My wife and I recently filed a claim for damages to our roof and siding, so we have a limited amount to work with. My brother-in-law works for a very reputable roofing/siding company in the NW suburbs of Chicago. He recommended that we replace our current aluminum siding with a Craneboard insulated vinyl product, due to how much quieter it will make the home, and how much stronger it is than a traditional vinyl siding product. They will also be rewrapping the home with Tyvek.

However, after reading varied reviews online, I have a concern about if there are any moisture problems with this product due to the foam backing essentially being flush with the sheathing. Our home is in the Chicago area, which receives a decent amount of precipitation and variable temps.

I know that there is a lot of "bias" when it comes to siding, and lots of preference - so I don't want to start a "holy war" of why Hardie board or wood is better, etc. - but just wondering if anyone has any experience with this type of siding and can speak to my concern at all. The siding does have "channels" along the back advertised as a "moisture management system" which in theory should allow water to drain out.

It is also advertised to not absorb moisture and allows the house to "breathe". In other forums I have read however, people have likened this siding to "installing a giant sponge against your home" and claim that the foam does absorb moisture and will rot your sheathing out over time.

I'm a little confused at how this product could be popular at all if it retains moisture and has the potential to rot your home away. Any input would be much appreciated!

BV006825

01:19PM | 01/25/15
What are the two holes in the underside of each panel used for?

BV007070

11:40PM | 02/22/15
Holes at the bottom off siding are weep holes in case moisture build up with the sheathing and siding

BV008882

12:55PM | 09/07/15
Crane board vinyl siding does retain moisture and the fact that the product is just covering up the original siding on the house doesn't help...it's like putting a bandaid on the exterior of your house instead of fixing the problem with real carpenters doing real carpentry. Plastic products like this actually are not allowed in most new HOA's because it constantly lowers the value of the home to make neighborhoods bend toward a trailer park look.


Post a reply as Anonymous

Photo must be in JPG, GIF or PNG format and less than 5MB.

Reply choose button

Anonymous

Post new button or Login button
Register