Latest Discussions : Plumbing


08:38PM | 05/20/04
Member Since: 05/20/04
2 lifetime posts
my daughter in college was recently charged $307 for replacement of a complete toilet because a plumber pulled a part of a hanger out of it. this was a beat up old toilet that was there when she moved in.

so 2 questions:

1. if you pulled a part of a hanger out of a toilet, would that be reason enough to replace a whole toilet?

2. my daughter says she didn't put anything like a hanger in the toilet. she has lived in the apartment for around 9 months. could that partial hanger have been in the toilet before she moved in?

any help would be appreciated.


10:14AM | 05/21/04
Member Since: 09/17/02
524 lifetime posts
If he pulled it out I don't see why the toilet had to be replaced.

plumber Tom

12:57PM | 05/21/04
Member Since: 05/10/03
801 lifetime posts
He was a rip-off. He should have gotten your daughters ok 1st, before replacing the toilet.

erik peterson

06:07PM | 05/21/04
Member Since: 06/23/03
223 lifetime posts
Maybe it was a scam, perhaps not....I think anyone making a judgement whether the work was warranted or not with the information twice-removed and possibly biased, is irresponsible. erik


01:43PM | 05/24/04
Member Since: 05/20/04
2 lifetime posts
hey guys thanks for the replies. what is so frustrating is that this company did the work without any input from my daughter or myself. the property management company was both judge and jury.

it appears that the toilet was removed before the stoppage was pulled from the plumbing.

Post a reply as Anonymous

Photo must be in JPG, GIF or PNG format and less than 5MB.

Reply choose button


Post new button or Login button