15 Iconic American Homes Torn Down Before Their Time

In desirable neighborhoods across the United States, the razing of a tear-down is a familiar sight. But this market-driven trend actually has a very long history. Consider this list of 15 eye-poppingly palatial homes, built with great care and at huge expense, that later fell victim to the wrecking ball.

Beacon Towers - Sands Point, New York

Beacon Towers - Sands Point, NY

Like a vision straight out of The Great Gatsby, this gothic-style Gilded Age palace situated on the shores of Long Island Sound was built in 1918 for Alva Belmont, who was once married to a Vanderbilt. William Randolph Hearst, of Hearst Newspapers and Hearst Castle fame, later owned the spired vision, but it was demolished just a few short years after he sold it.

Related: 12 Confessions of a First-Time Home Seller


William A. Clark House - New York, New York

William A. Clark House - New York, NY

A fabulously rich entrepreneur from Montana spared no expense building this 121-room behemoth that once stood on the corner of Fifth Avenue and 77th Street in Manhattan. Completed in 1911, the house cost $7 million (that's $178,075,000 by today's standards), in large part because of the extravagant materials used to construct it. Italian marble, parts of French châteaux, and wood from England’s Sherwood Forest once graced the elaborate home, which was reduced to rubble by 1925 and replaced with a luxury apartment building.

Related: 8 Ways to Age, Distress, Gild, and Add Shine to Your Next Project


Palmer Mansion - Chicago, Illinois

Palmer Mansion - Chicago, IL

Once the largest private residence in Chicago, Bertha and Potter Palmer’s home was one of the first to be built on the city’s famed Gold Coast along the shores of Lake Michigan. Erected in 1885 and torn down in 1950, the Romanesque mansion featured an 80-foot central spiral staircase and a collection of masterpieces by artists like Degas and Picasso. Many of these works now reside at the Art Institute of Chicago.

Related: House Tour: A French Castle Rises from Its Ruins


George Pullman Mansion - Chicago, Illinois

George Pullman Mansion - Chicago, IL

Another locus of Chicago’s mighty wealth was Prairie Avenue, where the home of George Pullman, the man behind the booming Pullman Company, once stood. The 7,000-square-foot home was clad in Connecticut brownstone and included a 200-seat theater and bowling alley. It was destroyed in 1922 as the surrounding neighborhood began to decline.

Related: 9 Ways Your Neighbors Can Screw Up Your Home Sale


Chetwode Mansion - Newport, Rhode Island

Chetwode Mansion - Newport, RI

With a white and gold interior inspired by the king's quarters at Versailles, this lavish 1903 mansion was purchased in 1934 by a young John Jacob Astor III as a home for himself and his new bride. They divorced five years later and placed the home and its contents on the auction block. The residence passed through a series of hands, then was burned and razed in 1973.

Related: A Home You Both Love: 12 Solutions for Your Biggest Decor Disputes

Flickr via Providence Public Library

Mark Hopkins Mansion - San Francisco, California

Mark Hopkins Mansion - San Franciso, CA

One of the founders of the Central Pacific Railroad, Mark Hopkins built a sprawling, palatial home on the peak of Nob Hill and topped it with a tower that was at the time the highest point in San Francisco. The mighty mansion survived the 1906 earthquake only to be consumed by the subsequent fire three days later. Its lot is now the site of the InterContinental Mark Hopkins Hotel.

Related: Check In: 10 Offbeat Hotels Worth a Special Trip


The Cliff House - San Francisco, California

The Cliff House - San Francisco, CA

Perched on a dramatic outcropping at headlands just north of Ocean Beach, the first Cliff House was built by an ex-Mormon elder from Maine, who constructed the mansion from salvaged lumber taken from a shipwreck on the rocks below. That early edifice gave way to several more incarnations of varying degrees of size and opulence. The current structure on this scenic promontory is a restaurant, part of the federally operated Golden Gate National Recreation Area.

Related: 10 Cliffhanging Houses to Fall For


C.M. Forbes Mansion - Portland, Oregon

C.M. Forbes Mansion - Portland, OR

This jaw-dropping Queen Anne Victorian was constructed on Park Place and Southwest Vista Avenue in 1887 by C.M. Forbes, the owner of a furniture store. It is believed to have been torn down in the 1930s. Today, a high-rise occupies the lot where the grand residence once stood.

Related: 17 Parts of Your Home You Never Knew Had Names


Bradbury Mansion - Los Angeles, California

Bradbury Mansion - Los Angeles, CA

Part of a vanished Victorian neighborhood that once stood on Bunker Hill in downtown Los Angeles, this turreted 19th-century beauty was turned into movie studio offices by the first decades of the 20th century. In 1913, film star Harold Lloyd dubbed the old house "Pneumonia Hall" on account of the dreadful drafts. It was demolished in 1929.

Related: 15 Old House Features We Were Wrong to Abandon


Old Governor's Mansion - Topeka, Kansas

Old Governor's Mansion - Topeka, KS

Occupying a generous site on Buchanan Street in Topeka, Kansas, this 1887 building by architect James Clinton Holland served as the state's executive mansion from 1901 to 1963. Its bay windows, staircase, and balcony were repurposed to become part of a nearby Ramada hotel, but the rest of the stately home met the wrecking ball.

Related: 10 Ways to Buy Better Curb Appeal for Under $50


Vanderbilt Townhouse - New York, New York

Vanderbilt Houses - New York, NY

The Vanderbilts amassed a fortune from shipping, railroads, and other industries, then used their vast wealth to build a series of incredible Beaux Arts mansions. A case in point is the townhouse erected at the corner of West 57th Street and Fifth Avenue by Cornelius Vanderbilt II. It was and remains the largest private residence ever built in Manhattan. The Bergdorf Goodman store now stands on the site.

Related: Bob Vila's Architecture Bucket List: 10 Must-See Wonders


La Ronda - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

La Ronda - Bryn Mawr, PA

This masterwork of Mediterranean and Spanish Gothic architecture, designed by famed Palm Beach architect Addison Mizner, was the pride of Philadelphia’s Main Line. Home to Percival E. Foerderer, a leather manufacturer, the residence was torn down in 2009 despite vehement protests by preservationists.

Related: 18 American Towns Every Old-House Lover Needs to See

Flickr via road_less_trvld

El Marisol - Palm Beach, Florida

El Marisol - Palm Beach, FL

Another lost masterpiece by Addison Mizner, this bubblegum pink Spanish Colonial Revival mansion stood on Ocean Boulevard in Palm Beach from 1920 to the 1950s. A beach house for investment banker Edward T. Stotesbury, it boasted an auditorium, a 40-car garage, and a private zoo.

Related: Hard Sell: 7 Pretty House Colors That Scare Buyers Away


Whitemarsh Hall - Wyndmoor, Pennsylvania

Whitemarsh Hall - Wyndmoor, PA

Edward T. Stotesbury’s Main Line home, often called the “American Versailles,” was one of the largest private homes ever built in America. Erected in 1921, the 147-room mansion was stuffed with paintings, tapestries, and sculptures, many of which later ended up in the Philadelphia Museum of Art. The building was torn down in 1980 and replaced by a townhouse development.

Related: 10 Fast-Growing Plants for (Almost) Instant Curb Appeal


Charles Schwab House - New York, New York

Charles Schwab House - New York, NY

Steel king Charles M. Schwab was considered bold for building his $6 million 1906 Beaux Arts palace on the “wrong” side of town, overlooking the Hudson on Manhattan’s West Side. Schwab went bankrupt in the stock market crash of 1929, and when he died 10 years later, he bequeathed the house to the city to be used as the mayor’s mansion. His offer was spurned, and in 1948 the building was replaced by a towering apartment block still known as “Schwab House.”

Related: Better Your Builder-Grade Home with 12 Old-House Details


Don't Miss!


Get the help you need for the home you want—sign up for the Bob Vila newslettertoday!