Latest Discussions : Roofing & Siding

jmsurpri

08:28PM | 07/28/03
Member Since: 07/28/03
1 lifetime posts
Hi,
Recently had our roof done. The contract specifically stated 1/2" plywood, but the roofer used OSB. We were out of town when the roof was done, so we only noticed it after the roof was completely done. We put a stop check on our payment and will be trying to get it replaced or reduced since he didn't follow the contract. Should I be worried about OSB? I am specifically worried about resale of the house. Will OSB reduce the value of my house? I live in Portland, Oregon
Thanks for any help
Jason

hoganem

06:12AM | 07/31/03
Member Since: 02/13/03
90 lifetime posts
Not sure about the particulars on your house, but I am building a new one and have spec's calling for 1/2" OSB on the roof. Almost every new house built today in midwest has 1/2" OSB on roof and 7/16" on sidewalls.

Nobody uses standard plywood anymore.

If the trusses or rafters are 24" apart or closer you should be fine.

DIYer

11:29AM | 07/31/03
Member Since: 06/16/03
12 lifetime posts
This UMASS site discusses OSB v. Plywood
http://www.umass.edu/bmatwt/publications/articles/osb_vs_plywood.html

Piffin

03:21PM | 08/03/03
Member Since: 11/06/02
1278 lifetime posts
OSB has become more common in southern places where snow loads are light.
I will never use it for roofing though. It will telegraph through the shingles and develope sags between rafters or trusses. The main reason it gets used is because it is cheaper by nearly half.

But what I will do or what half the country is doing has no bearing on this case. The contract specifically called for plywood and a cheaper product was used. That makes for a very strong case in court. The very least you should get from him is a knee bending, begging apology and the cost difference between the two materials which would be anywhere from twelve to forty cents per sq ft of roof area.

But I would be demanding more than that, because you will be looking at those sags for many years, if he leaves it there.

There is a newer type of OSB Called Advantech that is stronger and has more moisture resistant glues that might be acceptable for roofing but that is still ourside the contract. I would measure carefully in my mind to decide whether he is merely careless and slovenly in his trade practices or whether he is a shyster who intentionally defrauded you to decide how to proceed.



Post a reply as Anonymous

Photo must be in JPG, GIF or PNG format and less than 5MB.

Reply choose button

Anonymous

Post new button or Login button
Register